L

Lord Bruce of Bennachie (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 14 October 2026

Debate

UK and Poland: Security and Defence Partnership

Contribution

My Lords, those contributions anticipated a couple of things that I was going to mention. I start by thanking the committee for looking at this agreement and the noble Lord, Lord Johnson, for bringing this debate and his extremely helpful and clear explanation of the committee’s position. It is important that we recognise that British-Polish relations are important and, if we are to have an agreement, it needs to be meaningful, not just declarations of good will. The noble Lord, Lord Hannay, and others touched on the fact that the history of British relations with Poland over the past 100 years has rather ebbed and flowed. We recognised Polish independence in 1919 and, after we let down Czechoslovakia, we signed an agreement with Poland, a military defence pact, which ultimately took us into the Second World War when Hitler invaded it. But then, at the end of the war, we betrayed it, in effect, and handed it over to the Soviet Union. For that reason, many people in Poland came to this country. We have about 750,000 Poles living in the UK, partly because of that history. They certainly never want to go back to living under the totalitarian, brutal regime of the Soviets or any subsequent similarity, so of course they want strong defence and strong defence partners. I remember, and I am sure others will too, the continuous demonstration by Solidarity outside the Polish embassy in Portland Place. Many of us at the time spoke proudly and bravely in support of Polish democracy and freedom, thinking it was never going to come. But it happened, and they are free and democratic; long may it continue. Indeed, that is partly what this agreement is surely about. The consequence of that is that Poland is a remarkable country because it is right in the pivot of Europe—it gets trampled over, marched across and torn apart, and yet, historically, what an incredibly civilized, brave people they are. Maybe it is the history that has made them that way. Let us look at what has happened to Poland in the last 20 years. Its current GDP is $1.13 trillion. It is sustaining an annual growth rate of 3.5%; the UK would die for that. It does have a government debt of 65%, but again, look at ours. It has a deficit of 7%, perhaps that is the weakest part. But its GDP per capita growth, which was 36% of the UK’s in 1995 is now 81% of the UK’s and is expected to overtake ours within the next five years. On top of that, because it is where it is, it has a defence spending budget of 4.8%—substantially more than the United States, never mind anybody else—so it means business. It knows what the threats are, and it is organising for them—so I do not think the Poles will be interested in this agreement if we are not committed to it as well; that is what it will be looking for. Poland’s military capacity is better than was suggested. I read a brief saying that by 2030 it intends to have 300,000 full-time troops and 200,000 reservists, plus other land forces and air forces. Yet, it is fair to say that there is a complementarity between the UK’s defence capacity, for all its shortcomings at the moment, and Poland’s. Poland is a front-line state and therefore its capacity is based on that. We are not a front-line state, so we put our focus on to sophisticated weapons systems, the nuclear deterrent and intelligence, which we are definitely good at and can share. There is a complementarity there which is recognised by the agreement. Within all this, how can our Government demonstrate that they will turn this agreement into practical reality? My starting point is that the right thing to do would be to prioritise what is not necessarily the most ambitious but what can be delivered fastest. At this point, I was going to talk about the Joint Expeditionary Force. Canada is joining it, for heaven’s sake, and, as the noble Lord, Lord Hamilton, said, Sweden and Finland joined it before they joined NATO. I would be interested to know whether the Minister is aware of what the mood towards that is in Poland, because it seems to be logical for Poland. I can understand it was not necessarily logical for Poland to be a founder member, because it was looking towards the Baltic and the Arctic, but frankly the Baltic gets pretty close to Poland—indeed, Poland is a part of the Baltic. It would make sense as an outsider for it to be part of it. It would be interesting to know whether it feels it should be. We already, as I understand, have a rotating small number of troops in Poland, 100 or so, and, of course, we have 1,200 troops in Estonia. I have recently visited the European Centre of Excellence for Countering Hybrid Threats in Helsinki and the NATO Cooperative Cyber Defence Centre of Excellence in Tallinn. This year I have been to Lithuania, and seen what is happening on the border with Belarus and what the Belarusians, and indeed the Russians, are doing to the Baltic states and Finland. It was shocking to me, because it had not been brought home to me, that the Russians and Belarusians are advertising in central and southern Asia for people to come to Russia and Belarus, offering them livelihoods, visas and jobs—but when they arrive, they are immediately rounded up, driven to the border, and forced across into the EU in order to provide this destabilising impact. I saw a video of this happening, taken from the border post on the Lithuanian side, showing a van arriving, lots of people getting out, then another van arriving and a lot of armed people getting out and forcing them at gunpoint to climb over the border fence—at night, of course. This is what we are up against, and they know that. I happened to be at a meeting last night with Edward Lucas who writes a lot about this in the Times. He felt that one of the things the UK could do perhaps more dramatically than any others is to beef up the Joint Expeditionary Force, and make it a significant part of our defence ambition and capability. It is already there. I am not sure that beefing it up would be prohibitively expensive, but it would be a demonstration of serious intent. Finally, when looking at the article, that is one suggestion that would make sense. By that, I mean maybe put more troops in more places—not a huge number more but enough to make a commitment, a difference and deliver. Article 1 makes some reference to support for international development. Given that we have demolished our international development capacity, I should be interested to know from the Minister what the Government have in mind on that. Obviously, co-operation on counterterrorism crime makes absolute sense; it mells civil and military activity. Again, one of the things that we have disengaged from at our peril is Europol. I hope that, in November, we might start discussions on re-engaging in that. We were told that we would lose a lot because of that and my understanding is that we have actually lost a lot. That would be a logical framework for that kind of co-operation. Science and technology co-operation is partly about defence but also partly about intelligence, AI and general industrial capacity. Poland is proving itself to be a country of real dynamic potential and a partner with which we should be positively wanting to engage. I said in my earlier remark that we should not patronise Poland but respect it for what it is, has achieved and can contribute, and for how it can respond in like mind. I am left with two things only or perhaps two and a bit. One is the reference to energy co-operation, which someone said was controversial. I am going to be controversial, because I find it slightly concerning that we are discussing Russian oil and gas, and why we are not going to produce British oil and gas from our existing reserves. In the present climate, that makes no sense to me whatever. If we were to produce from Rosebank, for example, that would be oil that Russia would not have to export because we could export it to our European partners. It would also generate tax revenue, growth and jobs. As far as I am concerned, it is just ideology that is stopping us and it would be helpful if we were pragmatic about that. The other point was mention of the devolved Administrations. Can the Minister clarify that issue, because there is talk about another Bill about security? That would require clarification on what is UK-wide executive decision-making, albeit with consultation, and what is left to the devolved Administrations. We cannot, in a crucial situation, afford confusion as to who is responsible. My final point is that, if this treaty is to deliver in meaningful ways, as I said at the beginning of my remarks, will it require some modest secretariat to implement and develop it, and make sure that it is a live creature—not just a piece of paper that we have all signed, then gone away and done other things? I am absolutely certain that the committee is right: the cross-party support is real but there is a general desire for the Government to make it mean something and recognise that Poland will not respond if we do not have an offer that is worth responding to.

More from Lord Bruce of Bennachie (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.