Contribution
My Lords, I am very pleased to respond for the Government. I thank the noble Lord, Lord Lansley, for securing this debate and all noble Lords who have contributed today on such an important topic. I was trying to list each of their experiences, expertise and knowledge, which are highly extensive, but then I realised that I would use far too many of my potential 20 minutes on it. I have known two noble Lords for some years and met two others more recently, and I am getting to know their expertise even better, so I feel in very august company in responding. I hope that I can cover all their points. If for any reason there are any outstanding queries at the end of my 20 minutes, particularly given the extensive list from the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, I will of course write to noble Lords accordingly, but I will try to cover as many as I can.
The United Kingdom and the European Union are close neighbours and major trading partners. We share an interest in ensuring that markets are open, competitive and fair and that anti-competitive conduct does not harm consumers or hold back innovative businesses. This is particularly important as our economies continue to adapt to technological change, including the opportunities and challenges presented by digital and AI-enabled markets, mentioned in particular by the noble Lord, Lord Bruce.
In an increasingly interconnected global economy, conduct and transactions often cross borders and affect several jurisdictions at once. Effective enforcement therefore depends not only on strong domestic regimes but on practical co-operation between competition authorities. That is why the Government negotiated the UK-EU competition co-operation agreement, signed in Brussels on 25 February this year, as noble Lords are aware.
The agreement is the first supplementary agreement to the trade and co-operation agreement to have been signed since that agreement entered into force in 2021. It delivers on the commitment in Article 361 of the TCA, which provides for a separate framework for co-operation on competition matters. It is also the UK’s first ever international co-operation agreement, marking an important step in the Government’s ambition to deepen co-operation with international partners in competition on issues of shared interest.
The agreement will facilitate enhanced dialogue and operational co-operation between the Competition and Markets Authority, the European Commission and the national competition authorities of EU member states. This is the EU’s first so-called umbrella agreement, which extends the co-operation framework to the EU member states’ national competition authorities. In practice, this means competition authorities will be better able to co-ordinate where they are investigating similar or parallel cases. They will be able to notify one another of relevant enforcement activity, co-operate on investigations into cross-border anti-competitive practices and give careful consideration to each other’s important interests.
This matters because closer co-operation can make enforcement more timely, coherent and effective. It can help to avoid unnecessary duplication for authorities and businesses, so clearly outlined by the noble Lord, Lord Hunt of Wirral, and, ultimately, it can support more effective action to address harms, protect consumers and promote fair and dynamic markets.
This agreement also supports the Government’s mission to deliver economic growth. Effective competition in dynamic markets drives investment, innovation, productivity and, ultimately, growth. It strengthens the conditions for sustainable economic growth and delivers long-term benefits for businesses and consumers.
The Government have set out their priorities and expectations for the Competition and Markets Authority through their strategic steer. This emphasises the importance of considering action taken by competition and consumer protection authorities internationally and, where appropriate, ensuring that parallel regulatory action is timely, is coherent and avoids unnecessary duplication. This agreement will be an important tool in supporting those objectives. Noble Lords will rightly expect co-operation of this kind to be accompanied by appropriate safeguards.
The agreement is clear that each authority will continue to apply its own competition law and take its own decisions that reflect its important interests. It creates a framework for co-operation where that is helpful and appropriate, while fully respecting the independence of each authority and its enforcement activities. Any information sharing will remain subject to domestic law. The agreement also contains clear protections governing confidentiality, onward disclosure and the purposes for which information may be used. These safeguards help ensure that co-operation can take place in a way that provides certainty and reassurance for businesses, while protecting confidential information and respecting the independence of each authority.
Noble Lords raised the question of why the agreement does not include digital competition within its scope. At this stage, the priority has been to establish and bring into force a practical co-operation agreement that delivers tangible benefits for competition enforcement and consumers. Noble Lords will be aware that the UK’s digital markets regime came into force only in January 2025, after negotiations for the UK-EU competition co-operation agreement concluded. It is right that the regime is given time to bed in domestically and that experience is gained of its operation in practice before it is included in a formal co-operation agreement.
Furthermore, it is not unusual for the EU to adopt a phased approach to international co-operation agreements, where a first agreement establishes the foundation for co-operation, with more advanced co-operation considered later as relationships mature and practical experience is gained. Indeed, this has been the approach taken by the EU with other key partners such as Canada. The agreement should therefore be seen as a foundation rather than an end-point. That is why the agreement includes a review clause which provides an opportunity for both parties to consider whether co-operation should develop further in future.
Since signing, the agreement was laid before Parliament on 15 April, and the United Kingdom’s parliamentary scrutiny process concluded on 10 June. The European Parliament has since given its consent, and the agreement is now progressing through the European Union’s remaining procedures. We look forward to the necessary steps being completed so that the agreement can enter into force.
The agreement also gives us an opportunity to look ahead. It commits the parties to initiate a joint review within two years of entry into force and establishes a framework through which co-operation can continue to develop over time. As markets evolve, it is important that authorities are able to maintain a constructive dialogue and share expertise where that supports effective enforcement and better outcomes for consumers and businesses. Digital markets are naturally one example where the UK and the EU share the objective of promoting competition, supporting innovation and delivering better outcomes for businesses and consumers.
On the question around the timing with the EU on digital competition, noble Lords should be reassured that there is already close working between the UK and the EU on this, both as competition authorities and policymakers. The CMA and the European Commission maintain a close dialogue on competition matters, including digital markets. There are also existing opportunities for the UK Government and the EU to discuss digital competition established under the trade and co-operation agreement, as well as wider discussions through the G7 or OECD. Just this morning, UK and EU officials met through the trade specialised committee, where they had the opportunity to discuss level playing field issues, including competition and digital competition policy.
On domestic digital competition, the Government’s position is that the UK is very active in this space. Since the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act came into force, the CMA has made significant progress in implementing the new regime. Over the past year, the CMA has concluded three strategic market status investigations; designated Google in search and both Apple and Google in mobile ecosystems; imposed remedies; and launching a further SMS investigation into Microsoft’s business software and cloud services. In search, the CMA has already imposed conduct requirements relating to publisher controls, the fair ranking of search results and data portability.
Notably, the publisher controls remedy is a world first. It gives publishers greater control over how their content is used in AI-generated summaries. In mobile ecosystems, the CMA has secured commitments from Apple and Google relating to app review processes and data use, while also consulting on measures relating to app store steering and access to NFC functionality to support competition and innovation. In cloud services, the CMA has secured commitments from Amazon and Microsoft to improve interoperability and switching, while continuing to investigate competition concerns in business software and cloud licensing. The regime is already proving its worth in terms of both speed of impact and resilience to future developments in this fast-moving area.
As a number of noble Lords have highlighted today, competition challenges increasingly have an international dimension. This agreement does not seek to make our respective regimes identical—nor should it. Rather, it ensures that independent authorities can work together more effectively where there is a shared interest in doing so. In sum, the agreement represents an important step forward in competition co-operation between the UK and the EU. It provides a practical framework for closer engagement between our competition authorities, supports more effective enforcement in cross-border markets and establishes a strong foundation on which co-operation can continue to develop in future.
I turn to some of the specific issues raised by noble Lords. The noble Lord, Lord Carlile, spoke about complexity for businesses in Northern Ireland. Our intention is that the competition and co-operation agreement will reduce complexity for businesses operating in Northern Ireland through, for example, fewer duplicative requests for information. I have a detailed answer on standard essential patents, but I would be happy to write to the noble Lord to save a little time on that; as he might expect, it is all good news.
The noble Lord, Lord Bruce, said that he is interested in the advantages. Theoretically, this agreement could have real advantages for businesses subject to, for example, a merger investigation in both the UK and the EU, which could include a reduction in costs and duplicative requests for information—this was also of concern to the noble Lord, Lord Hunt of Wirral—greater predictability in outcomes and co-ordinated enforcement.
Further, the noble Lord, Lord Bruce, asked how the UK’s digital market regime will be able to adapt to developments in AI. I have already touched a bit on AI. The UK’s tools under the digital markets regime are intended to be flexible to address competition issues as digital and AI markets evolve. For example, the CMA’s publisher control conduct requirement in Google Search is a world first, allowing publishers to opt out of their content being used to power AI features. The CMA will act in areas that will have the greatest benefits for UK markets and consumers.
I turn to some of the detailed questions from the noble Lord, Lord Hunt of Wirral. The term “important interests” is not defined in the agreement in order to give respective competition authorities the flexibility to consider which enforcement activities may affect the important interests of the other party on a case-by-case basis. I hope that the majority of the noble Lord’s other, more general questions were covered by my earlier remarks; if not, I have committed to ensuring that he and others receive further detail on the specific questions and issues that came up.
In conclusion, I repeat—