L

Lord Hunt of Wirral (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 15 October 2026

Debate

UK-EU Agreement on Competition Laws

Contribution

My Lords, we are all very grateful to my noble friend Lord Lansley not only for securing this debate but for delivering what I found to be one of the most impressive speeches I have heard on this subject, displaying a wide knowledge of not only the background, but the way ahead, which is really what this debate should be all about. I am very grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Carlile of Berriew, for introducing me to standard essential patterns. Wow! I think we were all blown away by his expertise in this area. We have always regarded him as an eminent lawyer, but I had not quite appreciated the extent to which he has moved on a much wider stage. Let me make clear that we on these Benches support effective international co-operation in the enforcement of competition law. I agree with the noble Lord, Lord Bruce of Bennachie, that we need to hear from the Government some clear examples of how this new agreement is going to operate in practice. Where anti-competitive behaviour affects consumers and businesses across borders, competition authorities must be able to work together. Effective competition is essential if we are to have confidence in our economy, and it also encourages investment and innovation. I pause here to reflect on the words of the noble Lord, Lord Bruce of Bennachie. We in this country are proud to have some of the most brilliant scientists in the world. We have won more Nobel prizes than the rest of Europe put together. A few years ago, when I was involved as Cabinet Minister for Science, we launched the world wide web, which had been thought up by the most brilliant young 18 year-old Cambridge undergraduate operating at CERN, the Large Hadron Collider. I say to the noble Lord, Lord Bruce, that we thought at the time that things were moving so fast they were almost out of control with the development of the internet. I was the first Minister to receive a mobile phone, and I could hardly carry it because it was so heavy. Things move on, but it is very important to have effective competition because it is essential to the confidence we can have about the future, and it encourages investment and innovation. It also gives consumers greater choice and ensures that businesses succeed because they offer better products and services. This agreement makes a number of practical changes intended to achieve just that, in particular, where UK and EU competition authorities are pursuing the same or related enforcement activities. They will now have now have a formal framework through which they can co-ordinate those activities. I would be grateful if the Minister could clarify exactly how the Government expect this to operate in practice. Let us look back to some of the suggestions that have been made during this debate. One objective should surely be to reduce unnecessary duplication, yet greater co-operation between regulators could in some circumstances also make it easier for parallel investigations to take place. A business operating in both the United Kingdom and the European Union could still face two investigations, two sets of information requests and potentially different remedies. Can the Minister therefore say what safeguards there are to ensure that this agreement genuinely reduces duplication and regulatory burdens rather than simply facilitating parallel enforcement by different authorities? Article 3 states that a competition authority should notify the authorities of the other party where enforcement activity, “is likely to affect the important interests of the other Party”. Yet, as I understand it, “important interest” is not defined in the agreement. That leaves an obvious question for businesses and their legal advisers. What factors will the CMA or European authorities take into account when deciding that an important interest has been engaged? Do the Government intend, either independently or jointly with the European Union, to publish criteria or guidance explaining exactly how that test will operate? Of course, much of the UK’s competition policy sits outside this agreement. This debate takes place against a much wider question about the direction of competition policy in this country. Competition policy has to protect consumers and tackle genuine anti-competitive behaviour. But it must also recognise that Britain is competing internationally for capital, entrepreneurs and innovative businesses. The Government themselves have instructed the CMA to give greater consideration to growth and investment. The CMA’s report last year, as my noble friend Lord Lansley pointed out, outlined the four Ps —pace, predictability, proportionality and process—and says that its objective is to create a regulatory environment that attracts investment and gives businesses confidence. This is so important in the area that we are discussing. Technology is expanding fast. I acknowledge that. The noble Lord, Lord Bruce, is quite right—it is moving at pace. The CMA now exercises significant powers over some of the world’s largest and most innovative companies. The Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 gave the CMA an extensive new regulatory regime alongside its existing merger and competition powers. I believe that the Government therefore need to be able to demonstrate that the cumulative effect of these powers is supporting, rather than deterring, investment in the United Kingdom. What assessment have they made of the impact of the DMCC Act and the CMA’s digital market regime on investment, innovation and business confidence in the UK? Similarly, have Ministers reviewed whether the CMA’s existing merger control powers are appropriately calibrated to the Government’s stated objective, which I hope we all share, of making Britain one of the best places in the world in which to invest? Last year, the CMA acknowledged: “UK law gives us an unusually broad jurisdiction by international standards. This can create uncertainty over whether we will review a particular deal or not”. Only last week, we saw the Government intervene on public interest grounds in the BT-TalkTalk transaction under the Enterprise Act 2002, citing the continuity of telecommunications services. There may well be exceptional circumstances in which such intervention is justified but the Act also allows Governments to specify new public interest considerations. We should therefore be very careful that the public interest does not gradually become a cover for the political interest. The CMA itself has previously warned that a repoliticisation of merger control could well undermine business confidence. What assessment have the Government made of the risk that expanding ministerial intervention powers could create uncertainty, raise the regulatory risk attached to investing in the UK and, ultimately, deter investment? Finally, the Government announced a competition reform Bill in the King’s Speech in May. We were told that it would “make competition investigations faster and more predictable, reduce unnecessary burdens on businesses” and strengthen accountability. We are now in October and that Bill has still not been introduced. Can the Minister tell the Committee exactly when the competition reform Bill will be laid before Parliament and whether the Government remain committed to the reforms that were announced in the King’s Speech? We have raised a whole range of questions and we all now look forward to the Minister’s response.

More from Lord Hunt of Wirral (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.