L

Lord Bruce of Bennachie (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 15 October 2026

Debate

UK-EU Agreement on Competition Laws

Contribution

My Lords, I am genuinely grateful to both noble Lords for their technical knowledge and for introducing this debate. I freely admit that I am not an expert in this area, much as I believe strongly in effective competition law, but the report from the European Affairs Committee suggests that all it has done is to read the agreement—it gives us no guidance at all, whereas the two noble Lords have given us a very clear presentation of what the agreement is about. It is voluntary and non-controversial for practical purposes, because it is not enforceable. Based on genuine good will, it is a partnership to try to make our relationships work. Of course, the context we have at the moment is that, Brexit or no Brexit, the EU remains our biggest trading partner. The basis on which we trade with it is of mutual importance for us to get access and for it not to discriminate against us, and vice versa. So, whether you are for or against Brexit, we need to have rules for trading across the entire market. This is a practical step based on a voluntary agreement that has already been in place. I tried to look around and find out how many examples there are of this kind of co-operation under the existing situation. There were a few, including one in the motor trade and one in pharmaceuticals—reference was also made to digital, which I will come back to—but not very many. This suggests that we are still working fairly well with our European partners and that the main trading companies understand the rules and probably apply them. But you need rules enforceability where there are breaches or threats of breaches. In the light of this, I was slightly taken aback by the need for companies to be prepared for dawn raids and how they should react to them. There have been one or two in this context, and obviously they apply more widely. Having said that, I want to make a few points. If the Minister could give any examples of where this has already worked and how it might work more effectively, that would be helpful—certainly from my point of view—but, as the noble Lord, Lord Lansley, rightly said, investment purposes are part of the reason for this. Again, our investment opportunities are in a very dynamic state at the moment. Our relationship with the United States is extremely fraught. In many ways, the business-to-business, company-to-company and market-to-market levels are still working and will, I hope, continue to work, but they are being interfered with at the top and by major players in a very disruptive way. This has implications for the UK’s ability to attract, or fail to attract, investment. The question we have to ask is: to what extent are we prepared to compromise our own independence in order to attract investment on terms that are unfavourable or less favourable than we would like? In my view, that reinforces the need for us to reset our relationship with the EU, because it is a more trusted partner. Whatever we might worry about delay and bureaucracy, we understand each other much better, and we are on the same page. This point may not quite be relevant to this debate, but it concerns me—particularly in the digital context—that we are talking about three or four individuals whose personal wealth is the same as that of a medium-sized country. Two days ago, I heard the point that, individually, any one of them could end world hunger with their own resources. But that does not appear to be what motivates or mobilises them. What worries me is the fact that, in many ways, what they want to do with their wealth is use it powerfully to interfere in, pressure or blackmail markets. We need a robust but flexible competition arrangement that enables us to operate in and attract investment in those markets but also protect our own interests. It will not surprise noble Lords to hear me say that this is a step in the right direction, in terms of a reset, but I take the point made by the noble Lord, Lord Carlile, that, had we not left the EU, we would not have needed it. It has possibly given us a bit of space that we did not have. On the bigger picture, if we ever go back into the single market—I certainly hope that we will—the customs union and, ultimately, full membership of the European Union, to what extent does some of the space that we have been enabled to create during Brexit justify us not re-entering a very close relationship with the EU, in terms of the compromises and the benefits? Indeed, to what extent can we negotiate a relationship that takes some account of those changes? In my own dealings with the EU, in a whole variety of circumstances when we were members, the UK was an innovator, to the benefit of the EU. That is one of the reasons why it misses us right now. We were prepared not to go along with the centralist conventional wisdom and prepared to challenge it. This was one of the reasons why many of the smaller countries, such as the Benelux and Scandinavian countries, were so fraught when we left: they saw us as championing that view against what they saw as French, German and possibly Italian dominance. That balance has gone. That aside, it seems to me that if you are in business in the UK and more than 40% of your export market is across the channel, you have to conform to the rules and regulations that apply to be part of that market. What you want is to ensure that the rules are mutually and fairly enforced both here and there. This agreement seems to be designed to ensure that that is the case as far as competition is concerned. One of the problems of the past few years is that many small and medium-sized businesses will probably regard this agreement as of no relevance to them because they have stopped trading in the EU because of the technical difficulties. People might have said before Brexit that it was bureaucratic, but when we were in the EU the bureaucracy was negotiated at a senior level, and as a company trading within the EU, it was assumed that you were conforming to the rules and you did not have to prove it. Now you have to prove it, which if you are a big corporation, you can probably do at some expense, but if you are a small or medium-sized business, it is just too much trouble and too costly, so you do not do it. I think that is one of the reasons why we have suffered. Given that it is voluntary and unenforceable, will the Minister say what the experience of the arrangement we have had until now has taught us about how it will work? Will she perhaps give us one or two examples of where and how has it been applied? To come back to the digital space, I am a member of the International Relations and Defence Committee, which is in the middle of an inquiry into multilateralism in the changing world and is having a sub-inquiry into the role of AI in multilateralism. The noble Lord, Lord Lansley, made the point that things are moving at a terrifying pace, and it is difficult to know how any rules or regulations are going to work because they are ahead of the game on two counts. First, there is the technology that is being developed, and you have the extreme instance of it taking over the world and killing us all, and, secondly, the people creating these things do not know necessarily what they are creating or who will use it for good or bad. An awful lot of companies are already using AI and may be using it in ways that are hugely beneficial. Indeed, I think it was suggested that one of the reasons the previous quarter’s growth figures were slightly higher than expected was productivity bonuses from the application of AI. At the same time, AI could be used for anti-competitive reasons or for extreme competitive advantage, which is one of the reasons why I agree with the noble Lord, Lord Carlile, that we almost certainly need a separate agreement in the digital space. We have a real problem in the sense that 98% of AI innovation is being driven by the United States, a significant but small bit is being driven by China and the UK is third, although it has been pointed out that that is equivalent to being the third Gallagher brother. It is innovative and well targeted and gives us some advantage in a small way, but it does not give us any leverage in the market in terms of what is happening elsewhere. I believe it is important that we have a separate agreement, but I worry about how we can possibly get it in place fast enough and, having got it in place, about how it can work in a way that takes account of the pace of development. Funnily enough, the strength of this agreement is its weakness. It is flexible and unenforceable, but it is based on a genuine understanding of each other’s aspirations and a general requirement to work together to ensure that all parties know that there is an effective competition space and that there are parties who will work together to ensure that it is enforced. If the Minister can give some practical examples, I think that would enlighten us. I tried to find one or two, and I was slightly disappointed. All I was told is that there is an agreement, and I got every different aspect of this agreement, but not how specifically it might be applied. If not actual examples, then theoretical examples could help us better understand in practical terms from a business point of view what this will mean so either what it might threaten them with—not too much, I hope—and what it might provide them as an opportunity. If the Minister can answer those questions, I would much appreciate it.

More from Lord Bruce of Bennachie (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.