L

Lord Carlile of Berriew (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 15 October 2026

Debate

UK-EU Agreement on Competition Laws

Contribution

My Lords, it is a real pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord Lansley, who is expert, experienced and rightly much admired for his distinction. He has opened this debate showing that expertise, experience and distinction. I declare a past interest: for eight years, I was one of the part-time chairs of the Competition Appeal Tribunal. In my profession as a barrister, I take a close interest in collective actions and the availability of competition proceedings in the United Kingdom, which are a very important part of our service economy. We are referring to what I regard as a practical, sensible and proportionate agreement that has now been reached. It does not surrender any British sovereignty. It does not bind the United Kingdom to European competition rules—there is a great similarity between our competition rules and those of the European Union, but we are not bound by them in law—nor does it diminish the authority of our CMA or the UK courts, including the Competition Appeal Tribunal. What it does is recognise a simple reality: that modern markets do not stop at national borders. In the United Kingdom, the evidence of that is most clear in Northern Ireland. I happen to have the privilege of being the chair of the Northern Ireland Scrutiny Committee of this House. I make a plea to the Minister in relation to this process and this debate that every effort be made to ensure that no further complexities are applied to Northern Ireland businesses as a result of this agreement. Believe me, if she looks at our last committee report, she will see how complexity affects the way that businesses deal with competition in United Kingdom where Northern Ireland is involved. It is a truism that businesses that operate in the United Kingdom increasingly trade, invest and compete across the whole European continent. We are dealing with major mergers—some of them referred to by the noble Lord, Lord Lansley—cartels, abuses of market power and anti-competitive practices. The importance of those at root is that they frequently affect consumers and small and big businesses on both sides of the channel, so when you find that regulators are investigating precisely the same conduct in various countries, it must be in the public interest that they should be able to communicate effectively, co-ordinate where appropriate and avoid unnecessary duplication. That is especially so where there is the possibility that a remedy can be achieved without resort to the complexities that arise under the conflict of laws, as we lawyers call it. The agreement that we are considering creates a framework for that co-operation. It enables the relevant authorities to notify one another of investigations that may affect their interests, co-ordinate enforcement activity where appropriate and exchange information, subject to robust safeguards of confidentiality and due process. I believe that the regime for digital markets competition should be the subject of a separate agreement because there are very complex different issues that need to be considered there, but that agreement could take its cues from this agreement. For example, I take some professional interest in standard essential patents, SEPs. An SEP is a patent that protects the technology required to implement an industry-wide technical standard. That sentence refers to a huge raft of industry: telecoms, consumer electronics, connected vehicles—those connected to the internet, as most of the vehicles we drive today are—and the internet of things. Those who have standard essential patents have to commit to a FRAND—a fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory—agreement, which ensures that they have the advantage of their patents but the consumers do not have to pay through the nose. The practical result is that, for a car that is connected to the internet, for example, a one-off fee of around £20 or £25 is paid when the car is built, which guarantees that you can use your cruise control and everything else in that car for life. That is important and we need to think about it. The alternative to this agreement would be less efficient enforcement, greater regulatory uncertainty and increased costs for businesses and taxpayers alike. Parallel investigations conducted in isolation risk inconsistent outcomes, unnecessary expense and avoidable delays—and the delays in this country are short compared with most of the other countries we are talking about. Cartels do not respect national boundaries, fraud is neither patriotic nor passive, dominant firms operate internationally and digital markets are global in character. Regulators therefore require mechanisms for co-operation if they are to remain effective. Some may fear that any agreement with the European Union inevitably represents a step backwards from Brexit. Although I am not an enthusiast for Brexit— I am the exact opposite—I do not share the view that this represents a step backwards from Brexit. Indeed, Brexit was claimed to be the United Kingdom’s ability to govern itself, and this agreement is part of giving the United Kingdom the ability to govern itself. It is an exercise of that very sovereignty that we all cherish whether we are pro or anti Brexit. A sovereign nation is entirely free to enter into co-operative agreements that advance its national interests. With this agreement we retain independence but we are not isolated. It means that we can choose our partnerships in a manner that benefits our citizens and economy. Importantly, the agreement preserves the complete autonomy of all parties. Decisions remain in the hands of the United Kingdom authorities applying UK law and the EU authorities applying EU law. No supranational decision-making is involved and there is no obligation to reach the same conclusions if we do not want to. It simply gives us the opportunity to work better, with joined-up thinking and working and co-operation on what is sometimes an extraordinarily complex subject factually, technically and legally. In a world in which economic activity is increasingly interconnected, effective regulation requires dialogue, co-ordination and mutual respect between trusted partners. In my view, this agreement achieves just that.

More from Lord Carlile of Berriew (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.