B

Baroness Chakrabarti (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 October 2026

Debate

Public Office (Accountability) Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I have tabled Amendment 73 in this group. As we heard from the noble Baroness, the new offence of misleading the public really must be set at an appropriately high hurdle and should lead to prosecution only in the most egregious cases. None the less, it is crucial in pushing the culture change that is behind this whole Bill. There are many offences which require proof of actual harm to an individual or group before they are perpetrated, but there are many which do not. Drug supply offences and, more relevantly, perverting the course of justice are examples of the latter. My suggestion is that this offence should not require the subsequent hurdle of proving harm. The inclusion of proof of harm in the Clause 12 offence is, I suggest, unnecessary for similar reasons to those offences regarding the administration of justice. It would also lead to various egregious examples of misleading the public not falling within the current draft of the provision, or make them impossible to prove in reality. One real-life example is a chief constable who published false crime figures. This was intended to mislead the public, but it would be very difficult to establish actual harm. Recent revelations by my noble friend Lord Beamish regarding the nuclear test vets case indicate that he was misled by senior civil servants regarding a proposed compensation scheme, which, in turn, led to the public being misled. Again, this is a case in which, should it fall within Clause 12, it would be very difficult to prove harm. The Prime Minister himself gave evidence to the infected blood inquiry that, as Health Secretary, he was misled by senior civil servants as to what the then Government knew about contaminated blood products. This caused him, innocently, to make inaccurate statements to the public. These officials ought to fall four-square within the offence, but the requirement to prove harm would make that difficult or impossible. In recent days, there have been extremely misguided analyses of Clause 12 in the media. To be clear, the new offence targets only the promulgation of false facts by public officials, anathema to their function and mission to act in the public interest. My amendment would not alter the high hurdle of intention or recklessness, however we land with the understandable discussion begun by the noble Baroness, Lady Finn. My amendment would remove an unnecessary impediment to the offence working as intended in some of the most real and relevant cases. I urge the Committee to seriously consider removing the need to prove harm from an offence of dishonesty akin to other offences that I have mentioned.

More from Baroness Chakrabarti (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.