B

Baroness Brinton (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 October 2026

Debate

Public Office (Accountability) Bill

Contribution

My Lords, the amendments in the previous group proposed some changes to what an offence for misleading the public is. This group moves to the who and the how in an official misleading the public. I have laid Amendments 72 and 77 in this group. In 1989, in his interim report on the Hillsborough disaster, Lord Justice Taylor made it unequivocally clear that although many fans had been drinking, most of them were “not drunk, nor even the worse for drink”. He concluded that this formed an exacerbating factor but that police seeking to rationalise their loss of control overestimated the element of drunkenness in the crowd. However, the statements by the police to the press at the time said that they believed it was the behaviour of the fans, especially those who were drunk and violent, that was the cause of the tragedy—and many in the press believed them, with Liverpool fans carrying the blame even when Lord Taylor had contradicted this view. It took a quarter of a century for the report of the Hillsborough Independent Panel to be published, and it noted in September 2012 that Lord Justice Taylor was clear that Chief Superintendent Duckenfield was “untruthful” to Mr Kelly, the chief executive of the FA, about the inrush of fans forcing open the gate. The police led the press to believe that much worse had happened. Lord Taylor called it a “vilification” of the fans: he had not found one single witness to support any of these allegations. These lies were believed by many in the press, some of whom began decades of negative stories about the Liverpool fans that day. The fans, their families and the city of Liverpool have spent years trying to expose the truth; they are extraordinary. The Hillsborough Independent Panel is a testament to their fortitude. Sadly, however, they are not alone. Officials in the Post Office lied to the press about some of the Horizon postmasters and about the problems with the Horizon system. In infected blood, doctors and Department of Health officials lied for decades—including to the press—about the true risks of using blood from America and how serious the consequences would be for people. That is why I have laid Amendment 72. In the United Kingdom, the press and publishers are still thought mostly to be reliable sources of information for their readers. Victims of all three of these tragedies could not even begin to recover while these lies persisted. The consequences of these lies for postmasters were court cases and being exposed as criminals; in the case of those who caught HIV and developed AIDS from infected blood, many were treated as pariahs in the difficult AIDS era. The Bill creates other offences but, for some reason, ignores the role of giving misleading information to journalists or news publishers, and this amendment attempts to rectify this. Clause 12 is important. As we have discussed in the Bill, the duty of candour needs both carrot and stick. Clause 12 sets out the key ground rules relating to misleading the public and a public official or public authority intentionally misleading the public or being reckless as to whether their act will do so or not. This is critical to ensure that the duty of candour works. The stick is the offence for which there are definitely legal consequences, but there is a carrot in this too: all public authorities and any other bodies training their officials would have to ensure that they all understand the guardrails about misleading the public and that improper behaviour will have consequences—especially when talking to the media and journalists. To those who say that Clause 12 goes too far, I say that the family members of Hillsborough victims had to watch as their loved ones were not only killed that day but had their reputations unjustly trashed because police officers intentionally misled the press. Clause 12 would rectify that and stop it happening in the future, and there would be consequences if a public official or organisation deliberately misled the press. I beg to move.

More from Baroness Brinton (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.