L

Lord Wolfson of Tredegar (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 October 2026

Debate

Public Office (Accountability) Bill

Contribution

The noble Lord absolutely did. I was picking the positive bits to try to put the noble Lord, Lord Marks, in the best light possible. I was going to be much more supportive of Amendment 77 from the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, which is, with respect, a good probing amendment on the exception for those working for news outlets. It is particularly relevant in light of this weekend’s news that civil servants were seconded to the BBC fact-checking services. That was described by some as a clear conflict of interest. I can see how that risks undermining public trust in our national broadcaster. I invite the Minister to reflect on the importance of trust in our news outlets when he replies to Amendment 77, and to say what steps Ministers are taking to prevent apparent conflict of interests arising in the future. I turn to the Question that Clause 12 stand part of the Bill, tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Faulks, and the noble Baroness, Lady Falkner. This is a view, as they have said, which has been echoed by the Policy Exchange paper Legislating for Candour? on what the Hillsborough law is likely to do in government. Again, in his absence, in the previous group the noble Lord, Lord Carlile of Berriew, was not particularly complimentary about the paper. I am afraid I take entirely the opposite view; I think the paper makes a number of extremely persuasive points. With a foreword from noble Lord, Lord Butler of Brockwell, who has probably forgotten more about public administration than most of the rest of us will ever know, and whether one agrees with the conclusions or not, it is a very important contribution to the debate and I am sure that the Minister and his team will have looked at it. Like the noble Lord, Lord Faulks, I think a few of the words in the criminal offence are vague in the extreme. We have looked at “obfuscation”. Obfuscation might have been invented by lawyers to ensure that even the accusation of being unclear is itself unclear. I think it was Lord Armstrong who used the phrase “being economical with the actualité”, which was a fantastically obfuscatory way of saying what he was intending to say. Therefore, I agree respectfully with the noble Lord, Lord Anderson of Ipswich, that the words here need to be looked at carefully. It is not just “obfuscation”; we need to look at “repeated”. In most political interviews today, the politician says the same thing about seven times. Even in a single interview, you are going to satisfy “repeated”. On the word “significant”, what does it mean? When you see it in an Act, you wonder if it means “very substantial” or merely “not insignificant”. If it means the latter, it is a very low bar indeed. So, all those words need careful scrutiny. Again, I look forward to the Minister’s response on that. As the noble Lord, Lord Faulks, said, Clause 12 is not covered by the manifesto commitment. I will just say a further word about this. The noble Lord, Lord Marks, made a very important point about his Amendment 75; he said that it is a stand-alone offence, because it would be an offence even if there is no offence by the principal. He did accept—and was right to do so—that the normal principles of aiding and abetting would still apply. There is a real concern here because we are going to have this problem, I fear. Clause 12 could change the relationship between Ministers and civil servants. For example, a civil servant might say, “Minister, I think if you give the speech you want me to draft, you will be making a misleading statement to the public. I am not going to work on that speech because if you give it, you will be committing a criminal offence and I might be guilty of aiding and abetting a criminal offence”. Of course, the civil servant would explain their refusal as a principled objection to aiding and abetting the criminal offence but, in practice, there are various pressure groups who may put pressure on civil servants to take that view, or civil servants have their own political views. They are human beings; they may take a certain view due to their own political stance. I am not making this up out of thin air. Under the previous Government, there were issues of civil servants saying that they did not want to work on particular policies because they might breach international law. But the Minister is not personally liable under international law, and the civil servant is certainly not personally liable under international law, yet they were raising this as a reason to not work on the policy. I appreciate that this is a somewhat nuanced point, and it may be something the Minister does not want to reply to this evening, especially given the hour. However, I invite the Minister to think about it carefully and would be grateful if he would consider writing to the Committee between now and Report. I am conscious of the time, and I am also conscious that the noble Baroness, Lady Levitt, raised two points about the defence—changing “reasonable excuse” to “public interest” and changing the burden of proof. I was going to reply to those points in the next group, and I was wondering whether the noble Baroness, without any disrespect, would permit me to? As she said, they come in both groups and I have already spoken for long enough on this group.

More from Lord Wolfson of Tredegar (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.