Contribution
My Lords, I have a series of amendments in this group, but I start by picking up on a point made by the noble Baroness, Lady Jones. She and I will not agree on some aspects of this, but an important issue comes out of her amendment. I do not actually agree with her, as I am not convinced that the Secretary of State should be designating services at all. If this is to be a change to a point where we have track and train united, it is surely the job of GBR itself to work out what the network can and cannot deliver.
This drives very much to the points in my various amendments, certainly my earlier ones, which say that the Secretary of State must take into account
“the rail freight target under Section 17, and … the infrastructure capacity plan”.
We cannot have a situation where the Secretary of State is able simply to shoot blind to respond to political pressure and say, “I want to have four services an hour from Scunthorpe to London”, for political reasons or otherwise. There has to be a degree of realism in what the network can and cannot absorb.
One of the things that went wrong with franchising over the last 15 or 20 years was that, as the network became more crowded, a bid would come along to say that all these extra services were going to be delivered when the network could not actually cope. Before the pandemic, one of the key reasons for the lack of reliability was that we were trying to run too many trains on too little track. You have to remember that the network back in Victorian times, when it was twice as long, ran far fewer trains. It has settled down somewhat since the pandemic, but there are still parts of the network that are immensely overcrowded and where the ability of politicians to simply say that we are going to do that is limited.
The first elements of my Amendments 149 to 151 are designed simply to say to the Government that this legislation must put something of a break on what the Secretary of State can do. Regardless of where the service is designated from, it is simply not practical to have people sitting in the DfT deciding what train services should run. Indeed, I thought the whole point of this legislation was not to go back to a situation where politicians had control or carried the can for what went wrong in the network. It is designed to make this independent of politics, so why is the Secretary of State able to designate services at all? It is surely the job of GBR to balance all the competing needs of passengers, freight and capacity to work out the most realistic package of services that can be run. I am intrigued to hear the Minister’s defence of politicians and the Department for Transport being able to designate services at all.
I move on to the other amendments in my name. Here, I want to drive to the complete inconsistency in this legislation in a couple of areas. Why can the Mayor of London and, I believe, the mayor of Merseyside continue to commission services from a private company but no one else can? If the Scottish Government decide that they want to commission in exactly the same way that the Mayor of London does, why should that not be possible? Why does this legislation rule that out? The Minister needs to explain in detail why this is the case. Either we have a situation where every railway in the entire country is publicly owned and run—which we might disagree with but let us at least have a degree of consistency—or a situation where different bodies can commission from other providers, as long as they can demonstrate best value in doing so. Why is it one rule for one and another rule for another in the way this legislation is set up? I look forward to hearing the Minister’s explanation.
To me, the most important amendment here is Amendment 153A. I commissioned the review back in 2018 after the timetable fiasco, when it was quite clear to me—I had pretty much worked it out—that franchising no longer worked and we needed a fresh approach. I invited Keith Williams to carry out the research because I believed that one part of the future of the railways needed to be through employee-owned businesses. Indeed, I envisaged regional public interest companies, with the employees having a substantial stake. Rather than feeling free to go on strike all the time, they would have a stake in what they lost through revenues if they went on strike. They could benefit from working together to improve capacity, reliability and the rest. It is a matter of great regret to me that we did not reach that point, and the current Government have not reached that point.
If I remember correctly, I am addressing a Minister from the Labour and Co-operative Party, so why is it not possible for a co-operative to run part of the railway? Why is it not possible for an employee-owned business to run services on the railway? That seems completely incongruous. It runs against 150 years of Labour history, and it misses a great opportunity, because employee participation, generally speaking, improves the performance of a business or an operation. I see absolutely no reason why, in future, Great British Railways or the mayors of devolved administrations should not have the freedom to commission rail services from companies that are wholly or substantially owned by their employees—that is, co-operatives. If the Minister genuinely represents the Labour and Co-operative Party, perhaps he could tell me why he and this Government no longer seem to believe in co-operatives.