L

Lord Harper (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

My Lords, there are a couple of areas that I want to focus on. First, I strongly support my noble friend Lord Moylan’s Amendment 161, insisting that, in the rail strategy, Ministers include proposals for preventing and reducing the evasion of fares. I support it for two reasons: there is clearly a revenue purpose for doing this, but there is also a basic fairness purpose. There is nothing more irritating for passengers who pay their fares than seeing people who do not, and then nothing happens as a result. The one point I would add is that we should look at what we can build into the system to make it more difficult for evasion to happen. There was nothing more irritating—well, there were many things more irritating—but, on this particular aspect, one of the most irritating things, particularly when I was Secretary of State, was turning up at a station and finding that all the ticket barriers were open and people could just wander in and out without having to demonstrate that they had a ticket. I am afraid that, when I saw that, I used to take a photograph of said ticket barriers and send it to my special adviser. He used to then make the appropriate comments to the appropriate rail company about why they were giving away free money. It is just irritating. I therefore strongly support my noble friend’s amendment, particularly designing in—or out—people’s ability to evade tickets. The last thing we want is to spend a huge amount of money on staff and British Transport Police having to do the enforcement. The best thing is to work out a system where you make it as difficult as possible for people to evade paying in the first place. It is a very good amendment. The second set of amendments that my noble friend has tabled are those on discounts, with his specific focus on veterans. I make a plea to the Minister. In Clause 34, the Government clearly feel that discounted schemes are a good idea, but they have done that thing that often happens in legislation: as soon as you have a list of something, you have the undue specificity problem. The clause refers to young, elderly and disabled people and, although a subsection says that there is no prevention of other people being included, the fact that it has specified only those three groups of people will inevitably focus discounts in those areas. I ask the Minister to reflect on whether, without making the list excessively long, the specific proposal from my noble friend to include veterans, who are not necessarily otherwise included in one of those other sections, would be a welcome addition to the Bill. It would be helpful if the Minister could indicate—maybe not today—whether he would do so and would bring forward an amendment on Report. That would save my noble friend having to retable his amendment. I suspect that his amendment on veterans would get a lot of support. I was taken with the amendment spoken to by the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon. My only reason for not immediately supporting it has nothing to do with its quality. It is just that I am a bit loath to have lots of specific things set out in the legislation. I would prefer, frankly, that the discount fare scheme clause was much less specific or written in a way that would encompass the sort of scheme that she set out. It may be worth the Minister considering whether that clause could be better drafted to encompass what the noble Baroness wants to do with a scheme that reflects somebody’s usage—as opposed to their characteristics—but, if it is to cover characteristics as well, whether it should also encompass the one set out by my noble friend Lord Moylan.

More from Lord Harper (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.