Contribution
My Lords, this Government want to make train travel more affordable for everyone, which is why we have announced the first freeze in rail fares for over 30 years. Affordability will also be a key consideration for the Secretary of State in setting the strategic parameters for fares. That is why, on 15 September, we published a fares factsheet, setting out the objectives the Secretary of State will pursue and how this will enable wider reform of fares, ticketing and retail.
Looking at Amendments 161 and 161A, I completely agree with the figures that the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, raised, on the rough levels of fare evasion. Although the long-term rail strategy will reflect the need for GBR to protect its revenue, contrary to Amendment 161, I do not believe that the strategy is the appropriate place to propose exactly how it will do that. The Secretary of State and I announced in July an additional £33.4 million to crack down on fare dodgers, with new ticket gates for stations across England, but we must allow these decisions to be made at the right level and in an agile manner. For example, having provided that money, I think it is the job of railway operators to decide which gates go in which stations and will have the most impact.
The noble Lord, Lord Moylan, is right to raise fare evasion and I agree with him absolutely that we do not tolerate any assault on any member of staff for any reason, including fare evasion. However, decisions on how to tackle fare evasion must be a matter for Great British Railways, in collaboration with the British Transport Police and other stakeholders, including mayoral strategic authorities.
The noble Lord, Lord Moylan, referred to the framework. It will be in place by the end of 2026. It is preferable for railway operators to formulate their own detailed approaches to fare evasion because we know that this is an evolving and fast-moving area. It is certainly not something that one would want to see in a 30-year strategy. I say in answer to my noble friend Lord Berkeley that open access operators collect their own fares and make sure, as should all operators, that the people who travel with them have paid.
Amendment 161A concerns the structure of fares. I think that it is clear in the Bill that the accountability and transparency sought by this amendment are already there. The Secretary of State will set fares objectives and controls within which GBR must operate. Guidance on how GBR should set fares will be periodically reviewed alongside funding decisions—clearly, because, as noble Lords have remarked, the railway consumes a great deal of public subsidy—and reflected in GBR’s five-year business plans. GBR would then manage fares within that framework.
The fares policy will also be aligned with the long-term rail strategy. This means that GBR will be expected to run the railway on a financially sustainable, efficient and value-for-money basis, balancing fare income with public funding while supporting an affordable and accessible railway. I believe that this gives the Secretary of State appropriate oversight of fares policy, reflecting her accountability to Parliament for the overall objectives and public funding of the railway while allowing GBR to take day-to-day fares decisions. Any significant changes would need to be consistent with the business plan, which the Secretary of State will have already signed off. This is clearly a superior model than requiring the Secretary of State to approve changes to the structure and level of fares, which would duplicate the existing provisions and potentially reintroduce the very detailed ministerial involvement in the railway that the Bill seeks to prevent.
I turn to Amendments 162 to 179, save for Amendment 165, which I will come on to later. Discounted fares are vital in keeping rail travel affordable for many passengers. As has been remarked, under Clause 34, discounts for young, senior and disabled passengers will continue to be protected in statute. We know that the cost of rail travel can be a significant barrier for these groups, given that they are likely to be on lower incomes than other adults. Maintaining these concession schemes in primary legislation ensures that we continue to have an inclusive railway. It also supports access to employment, education, training and vital services.
This is not to say that other concessionary schemes are not important or that they will not be continued. However, the noble Lord, Lord Harper, had it when he said that there is a question around specificity. I agree with him; let me explain why. In relation to veterans, the Government fully recognise the enormous contributions that have been made by members of the UK Armed Forces, veterans and their families. The UK Armed Forces railcards are one way in which we honour the sacrifices made by this community. Meanwhile, the 26-30 Railcard was introduced in 2018 in recognition of the comparatively high living costs and low earnings of this age group—challenges that remain nearly a decade later. There are no plans to withdraw any of these concessionary schemes or to reduce the level of discount.
Let me explain, though, why we do not see the desirability of putting this into statute. Clause 34 has been drafted to provide flexibility in the design and operation of discount fare schemes. By minimising the number of schemes listed in the Bill, we enable GBR to update and evolve concessionary offers as the needs of passengers change. Amendment 166 would undermine the ability to develop these offers, even where changes would plainly benefit passengers. Take, for example, recent changes to the non-statutory 16-17 Saver Railcard, which gives young people half-price travel. Saver Railcards bought on or after 17 August 2026 are now valid for a full 12 months from the date of purchase; they will no longer automatically expire when the holder turns 18. Similarly, we expanded eligibility for the statutory Disabled Persons Railcard in September; passengers with a long-term impairment, health condition or neurodivergence that has lasted, or is expected to last, at least 12 months and significantly affects their ability to use rail services will now be able to apply. These kinds of beneficial and common-sense adjustments would be far more difficult if Amendment 166 were to be accepted.
There are currently two railcards for the Armed Forces. His Majesty’s Forces Railcard costs £21 a year and offers one-third discounts for serving personnel, their spouses and dependent children. The Veterans Railcard is £35 and gives one-third off adult fares and 60% off for accompanying children. I hasten to add that that would not be possible under Amendment 179, which rigidly seeks to set discounts at one-third off—no more and no less. In future, it might be desirable to combine these railcards to ensure consistent terms and conditions between veterans and serving personnel and their families, or to update the terms to make the railcards more relevant to the people who use them. GBR should be able to consider options like this. If we enshrine more schemes in primary legislation, as the noble Lord proposes, it becomes rather difficult to amend and improve them. For the avoidance of doubt, I say from this Dispatch Box that the Government are committed to continuing these entitlements and, as I have just described, will endeavour to improve them.
On Amendment 165 from the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, I expect GBR to continue providing current railcard schemes while innovating to develop new options, which is why I welcome the intent of the noble Baroness in tabling her amendment as well as the remarks of the noble Lord, Lord Hampton. Once established, GBR will be able to consider various means of encouraging more people to travel by rail. Customer loyalty schemes are one of many possible tools. The noble Baroness is right to draw attention to the potential benefits of such schemes. Where they have succeeded, it has generally been due to careful commercial design and by responding to customer behaviour, as demonstrated by LNER’s domestic model and the various international programmes that she described. Unless I am mistaken, those international examples do not rely on specific legislative provision. Loyalty schemes are simply one form of discounting and, in our view, do not need to be expressly provided for in this Bill.
I want GBR to have the opportunity to assess the evidence and determine what works best for passengers before we prescribe it. Any loyalty scheme would, for instance, need to reflect the diversity of rail users. The needs of regular commuters may differ significantly from those of occasional leisure travellers, and different market conditions may apply in each case. I agree with the noble Baroness on the potential benefits that loyalty schemes can bring and I am grateful to her for raising this issue. I am happy to discuss it further with her outside Committee. I hope that what I have said enables the noble Lord and noble Baroness not to press their amendments.