Contribution
My Lords, I have a few amendments in this group. I strongly oppose Clause 46 because it is a central part of how the Bill deregulates passenger-related and accessibility-related duties, moving all responsibility away from the much stronger regulator, the ORR, to the weak Passengers’ Council, which, as previously discussed, is little more than the existing Transport Focus.
The first issue is the way this works within the internal mechanics of the Bill. It is complicated but vital that this two-step deregulation is spelled out on the record. First, all forms of licensing are deregulated because they no longer need to have regard to the general duties. Secondly, the role of standard setting is moved away from the ORR to the Passengers’ Council, which is not subject to the general duties. Clearly, this severs all links between the general duties and the standard setting.
The ORR is the much stronger regulator, so there is a significant safety dimension here too, especially when it comes to accessibility, which has many crucial links to safety and operations. The ORR has years of institutional knowledge and a much superior perspective on how this system fits together, so even if it could be justified to move consumer rights and passenger standards-related issues away from the ORR to the council, it could never be justified to sever this link between accessibility and rail operations. If anything, accessibility needs to be treated with the same seriousness as safety from a regulatory perspective.
The same point about safety should be made even more strongly about monitoring and enforcement. Under current legislation, serious issues such as licence breaches are dealt with by the ORR, meaning that they get the oversight of the regulator most expert in safety and operations. According to the Bill, such issues can now be dealt with by the council alone, a body with a much weaker negotiating position, under an overarching duty of cost efficiency. It is much less knowledgeable about how the operational aspects of the railway fit together.
The watchdog’s only recourse, where an operator fails to comply, would be to refer the matter to the ORR, without any standards or timescales for this referral. This creates scope for operators to delay, obstruct or exploit a non-enforcement stage before the ORR can become involved, potentially more than doubling the timescales and meaning that later enforcement action would take place according to much weaker standards. For these reasons, Amendment 190 from the noble Lord, Lord Evans of Guisborough, is important because it would make sure that referrals were always made to the ORR. His Amendments 191 and 192 would require that the ORR always acts on these referrals.
On my Amendments 201A and 202B, Amendment 201A would add to this approach with a backstop to ensure that any serious issues or licence breaches relating to rail operations, safety or accessibility are always directly referred to the ORR and never diverted down the much weaker route of the Passengers’ Council. Amendment 202B addresses the main weakness in Clause 49, in which GBR must consult the Passengers’ Council when it “appears” to GBR that the changes
“will significantly affect the interests of the public”.
This is clearly a subjective standard. This amendment would make it an objective standard when the change would reasonably be expected to have a significant effect.
On that note, I am strongly in favour of Amendment 209 from the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, the wording of which also would remove this subjective standard while ensuring that the London Transport Users’ Committee is also a statutory consultee when it comes to services operating within the London area.
Amendment 330JA concerns the Disabled Persons Transport Advisory Committee. This is a very credible and active statutory body, which is an adviser to the Secretary of State on rail policy matters. As I understand it, it was previously thought that DPTAC’s role in rail policy would be expanded to GBR. This was included in the Conservatives’ draft rail reform Bill in 2014—so they did something right, I suppose. The alternative would be greatly to reduce its statutory role in policy, since most decisions relating to rail policy and operations and many of the strategy functions currently held by the DfT will move to GBR. Hence, my Amendment 330JA would amend the Transport Act 1985, which originally established the role of DPTAC. It mirrors exactly the amendment in the Conservatives’ draft Bill. Considering the Bill has no requirement for disability-related advice or the participation of disabled people, extending the role of DPTAC is really the minimum that should be done. The committee already exists and is well thought of, so extending its statutory role in this way would involve minimal cost and change. If any explanation exists to justify this deregulation, I would really like to hear it.
In the previous group, I mentioned my Amendment 204A, which I should not have done; I am sorry about that. It is a crucial amendment solving another major issue with the Passengers’ Council: the fact that there is no link to real-life passengers whatever. Public engagement and consultation is not only necessary for fairness and openness with the public and disabled people; it is also one of the most valuable possible forms of input for the benefit of the council itself. Passengers and campaigners are crying out for a proper system of engagement, and this would finally establish a much-needed link with what passengers are actually experiencing and their priorities for change. With all due respect to the noble Lord, Lord Hendy, who is more expert than the people using the network every day?
The amendment would introduce a new clause that would require the Passengers’ Council: to establish arrangements for the input of passengers; ensure that they can contribute to its work programmes and priorities; ensure that they can input on national policies; ensure they can receive transparent information about its activities and the outcomes of its work; and prioritise arrangements for engagement with disabled people and their organisations, as well as other groups protected under the Equality Act 2010. I would like a fair world, and what I am trying to do with my amendments is to create a fair Bill.