Contribution
My Lords, I will speak to four amendments in this group, most of them relatively briefly. I support Amendment 213, moved by my noble friend Lord Moylan, who clearly set out the reasons for it. I add only that it is a useful amendment because it effectively changes the presumption, which is helpful for GBR. It would still allow the ORR to say that you need not have driver-only operation if there is a very good reason for doing so, but it would mean that the default is that you would have it.
This comes back to a discussion we had the other day. If you are going to run a competitive railway and deliver it at a reasonable cost, the advantage of staff not doing jobs that can be done more efficiently is that this frees up GBR to deploy its staff in a way that better serves customers. I briefly refer to our discussion on Monday about the need to have more staff focused on supporting passengers with disabilities and other needs. There are only so many people to go around and there is only so much cost that can be borne, and delivering this driver-only operation more efficiently enables GBR to deploy staff to serving passengers in the way we wanted to see when we discussed this on Monday.
All I add to my noble friend Lord Moylan’s Amendment 305A on pensions is that it is not just important, in getting this transition right, to protect employees’ rights and financial benefits. That is of course very important, and his amendment does that. The second thing about having a proper transitional process is making sure that the management of what is a large pension scheme is efficient. Sadly, with the management of Civil Service pensions moving from one provider to another, we have already seen that, if that is not well handled, current employees trying to find information about their pensions and people who are retiring and need that information get a very poor service. If the pension scheme is forced into a transitional process too quickly, not only does that put at risk ensuring that the financial rights of pensioners are protected but it potentially delivers terrible customer service, which can be incredibly damaging for pensioners. Making sure that that is handled in a sensible and orderly way is beneficial for both GBR and its workforce. There is no interest for anybody in having that not well handled.
I support Amendment 320 on workforce productivity, which my noble friend set out well. We talked a lot about costs and who bears the cost of that—the taxpayer or the fare payer—but the important point is to reduce the cost of delivering rail services so that, however we split that cost, it is as low as possible for both taxpayer and fare payer. My noble friend sets out a good scheme for doing so.
I absolutely support the thrust of Amendment 330C, to which the noble Lord, Lord Hampton, just spoke. If he were to bring it back on Report, depending on what the Minister says, the wording would need tightening up, because he said he wanted GBR to be the largest provider of apprenticeships as a proportion of its workforce, which is not what the amendment currently says. I support the first part of it, which is about increasing the number of apprenticeships, but I am not sure that having a target for GBR to be the biggest one is a sensible thing to write into statute.
The thrust of the noble Lord’s amendment was to have GBR become a significant provider of apprenticeships across, importantly, the whole of its workforce, not just what is currently the Network Rail side—the engineering side and people delivering the infrastructure—but the whole business, including customer services and some of the back-office operations, such as finance and managing it. All those provide great jobs for people and training for that workforce. As the noble Lord, Lord Sikka, mentioned, a significant number are getting towards retirement age, and training a workforce and making sure that we have a workforce for the future is valuable. I commend that amendment to the Committee.