L

Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 21 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

I certainly believe so, but I am happy to go and check with them. As I said, we would not dream of transferring any staff, whether large or small in number, without making sure that those arrangements could be properly carried out. I think the scheme is well administered and capable of doing everything we would want it to in the timescale we are looking at, but I will confirm that. With regard to Amendment 305B, the Government are committed to engaging transparently with employees, trade unions and the wider industry as rail reform is implemented. As I have already outlined, the transfer process will be subject to established TUPE consultation requirements, ensuring that staff and their representatives are informed and consulted in good time before any transfer is made. Those discussions will take place over a number of months ahead of any transfer, following familiar and well-understood processes that help ensure that transfers of this significance are delivered in an orderly and effective manner. However, it is extremely unusual for there to be a requirement in legislation that the entire corporate and employment structure be settled 12 months in advance in order to use the power in question. In a reform of this complexity, those arrangements will necessarily evolve through consultation and negotiation with relevant stakeholders. This requirement would remove a degree of flexibility for the Secretary of State to respond to any developments or adjust aspects of transfer or design in response to consultation and it risks locking the Government into proposals before that process is complete. That could ultimately delay the transfers themselves and the establishment of GBR. I do not therefore consider a need for further legislation on this matter. Amendment 306 would require the Office of Rail and Road to issue both train driver licences and train driver certificates. I should explain that under the current Train Driving Licences and Certificates Regulations 2010, licences are issued by the ORR while certificates are issued by employers such as train operators. The reason for this is that the overall train driving licence issued by the ORR is a national-level qualification but, in comparison, the certification issued by employers is designed to demonstrate that drivers are competent to operate particular routes and rolling stock. It would not be appropriate to transfer the certification function to the ORR, as the employers are best placed to understand which services trains drivers will be deployed on and then to train them appropriately for that specific rolling stock. The ORR would not have the route and rolling stock expertise to perform this function. Moreover, Amendment 307 proposes specific consultation requirements. The existing drafting requires government to consult with representatives of train drivers and any other person deemed appropriate. This enables a proportionate and flexible approach to consulting on a topic that involves significant technical and medical detail. It involves the Government consulting people—for example, including medical professionals—if needed, but acknowledges that, each time the power is used, a different set of consultees may be appropriate, depending on the use of the power. On Amendment 306A, I reassure my noble friend Lord Sikka that there are no plans to change the existing train driver licensing and certification fee arrangements. They are not currently paid for by drivers and that will not change. In fact, his amendment would prevent the status quo from staying as it is by making it so that only GBR or train operators can pay fees in the regulations, whereas today the ORR pays the licence fee, which is less than £10. That is then recouped through the rail safety levy. Employers currently only pay for the certification aspect of the fees and I expect them to continue to do so. The power in Clause 94 and the specific subsection that he seeks to amend does not create a targeted mechanism to introduce fees for drivers in obtaining their licences, including any training. The intention of this power is to allow the train driver licensing framework to evolve over time, as opposed to being frozen as it is currently. There are clear safeguards attached to the power, including mandatory consultation, impact assessments and parliamentary scrutiny. I hope that this provides my noble friend with the reassurance that he is looking for. On Amendment 308 of the noble Lord, Lord Bradshaw, spoken to by the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, the powers in Clause 94 are critical if the Government are to ensure that the framework for train driving remains robust, responsive and fit for purpose in the years ahead. They will allow the regime to evolve in line with best practice, incorporating advances in technology, innovation, operations and safety knowledge. For instance, the legislation currently names the Ishihara test as one to be used by doctors when assessing colour blindness, despite there being more modern methods available to industry that have arisen since the legislation was first made—for example, the colour assessment and diagnosis test or the Farnsworth dichotomous test—and are more effective. The ability to update this legislation on an enduring basis will help to modernise the framework and support health and safety outcomes for drivers, as well as avoiding operational impacts such as train drivers being unable to be deployed on account of not passing outdated medical tests. That means that the legislation needs to cover both international and domestic operations, which Clause 94, as drafted, will provide for. I turn to Amendments 318, 344 and 330C. On the amendments of the noble Lord, Lord Hampton, I first say that the Government and I strongly support the intent behind this arrangement. I hope that noble Lords took note of last week’s announcement that Great British Railways will create up to 600 new apprenticeships over the next four years, demonstrating our commitment to investing in the workforce of tomorrow. These new rail foundation apprenticeships are possible thanks to the continuing work of Network Rail and DfT Operator, together with industry and Skills England through the rail apprenticeship and skills funding industry steering group.

More from Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.