Contribution
My Lords, first, I congratulate my noble friend Lord Parkinson of Whitley Bay on his ingenuity in managing to get amendments on heritage railways into many groups in the Bill, and in therefore having the opportunity to explain to the Committee how important they are.
Again, I wish to use this opportunity briefly to mention the Dean Forest Railway. It is a heritage railway based in the Forest of Dean, which is in my former constituency and is where I currently live. As I have said previously, it runs on its own track but interacts with GBR infrastructure at Lydney. Access to that network is, therefore, important. So, again, I congratulate my noble friend on reminding the Committee of the importance of heritage railways and the importance of fair access to GBR infrastructure.
I say at the outset that, as I think the Committee can see, this whole issue of access to infrastructure is one of the biggest concerns people have, given that this group and the following five groups are all about access. We are going to spend the rest of the day here, I think, talking about access in one form or another, including how it is decided and how the processes work; that is very important.
I should say at the beginning—to save the Minister pointing this out—that the draft rail reform Bill for which I was responsible when I was the Secretary of State also removed decision-making around access to infrastructure from the ORR and gave it to GBR. So, in principle, I do not have a problem with that. The difficulty I have, which is why I am supportive of the comments made by my noble friends Lord Lansley and Lord Young, is that the Government have taken the very important decision, which we would not have taken, to change fundamentally the context in which GBR will make these decisions.
When we were thinking about it, we wanted to bring together decision-making on track and train—I support that—but we did it in a context where we were envisaging most, if not all, passenger rail services being operated by competing private operators. So, when GBR was making decisions about access to infrastructure, it would have been making decisions between competing private operators, open-access operators and freight operators. It would not have had its own passenger rail services which it would have been tempted to self-preference, as my two noble friends have referenced.
The context that we are now in—where, in the next couple of years, most passenger rail services will be operated by GBR or its own companies—clearly sets up at least the temptation for self-preferencing. In the meeting the Minister had with me—I am grateful to him for that meeting and for his remarks at the beginning—and those he had with my two noble friends, he has provided some assurances to some extent about how these powers will operate. However, independent operators—open access operators, freight operators, and indeed those operating international rail services—still have concerns. Obviously, there are decisions being taken at the moment about competing operators through the Channel Tunnel, and those are also decisions that will that fall to GBR.
Those operators will hear the Minister’s assurances and, I think, to some extent will be reassured, but it will be important for their boards and investors to have some of this reinforced in statute, to give them confidence. That is where I would support the thrust of my noble friend Lord Lansley’s Amendment 224, which would provide that
“equitable, non-discriminatory and transparent conditions”
are in place, and Amendments 228 and 229, which would reinforce the presumptions in place for open access operators.
Again, I ask the Minister, notwithstanding what he has already said, and even if he is not supportive of Amendments 224, 228 and 229, to reflect on whether there are things that can be done in the Bill to strengthen and put into statute some of his assurances. I ask him to reflect on whether he could bring those forward on Report, which would obviate the need for others to do so.
Finally, I come back to this point about future capacity, to which my noble friend Lord Young referred. The Bill as drafted says in Part 2, on the capacity duty, that GBR—my noble friend is right—
“must exercise the functions so as to ensure that it retains sufficient capacity over GBR infrastructure.”
Then there are two conditions. One is
“the carrying out of work necessary to maintain and improve GBR infrastructure”.
That sounds perfectly sensible, but it also talks about
“the operation of GBR passenger services and of railway passenger services that it expects will in future be GBR passenger services”.
The Minister at least provided reassurance that the “expects in future” has to be pretty firm. It cannot just be some vague notion that, at some point in the future, maybe someone might provide some rail services.
That was helpful, but I would challenge the presumption of self-preference, giving GBR the ability to reserve capacity for services that, even if it is quite solid that they might turn up in a year or two, it is not currently providing. An open access operator could come along and say, “We have a pretty solid plan to get these services delivered within a reasonably short timeframe. We have our plans to get our rolling stock. Here is our application”. I do not see why GBR should be able to turn that down, even if it may want to provide those services in the near future. If someone is ready to do that now, can operate that on a commercial basis and does not require taxpayer subsidy to do so, that would be a better use of the infrastructure than assuming that GBR was able to do it.
Also, not allowing GBR that self-preference would mean that GBR has to get a move on. In other words, if there were services that it wanted to provide, it would have to get a move on in doing its planning, securing its rolling stock and getting on with it because otherwise, somebody else might come along and do it more quickly. Setting up that tension and that competitive process would be sensible, good for passengers, and good for getting rail services delivered more quickly. It would set up a bit of competition.
I am therefore not sure that I agree with the ability for GBR to reserve that capacity for future use at all. Notwithstanding that, there are the valid questions that my noble friend asked about the extent to which that future use has to be underpinned by a contract or some clear commitments that the Secretary of State has made about what she intends to do, or whether it can be vaguer than that, notwithstanding that it cannot be at the outer edges of vagueness.