Contribution
My Lords, I am grateful to the Committee for listening to my earlier speech, and noble Lords will be relieved to know that I have deleted quite a lot of the remarks I would otherwise have made, because I have said them already. The only thing I would say to the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, is simply that the present system does not work. I will not repeat the examples that I have used, but nobody is currently in charge of allocating proper use of some extraordinarily expensive infrastructure on the railway and that is what we are seeking to deal with.
Looking at Amendments 222, 224, 225, 228 and 229, I again place on the record that the Government fully recognise the value of open access, international, freight, heritage and charter rail operators, and Clause 59(2)(a) requires GBR to set out the process by which third-party operators, including all the ones I have just mentioned, can apply for and obtain access to the network. The draft AUP published for consultation last month provides further detail. I have discussed it individually with some noble Lords and encourage all noble Lords to review it and engage with the consultation.
Fairness and non-discrimination are at the heart of this process. GBR will be subject to public law principles and competition law, with the ORR continuing to provide independent oversight and enforcement. GBR will be bound by the duties in Clause 18, including duties to promote freight and promote the interests of passengers, and it must have regard to the rail freight growth target set by the Secretary of State under Clause 17. As a result, GBR must consider the interests of all network users when determining the best use of the network and cannot simply favour its own services.
On heritage rail specifically, I again reassure the noble Lord, Lord Parkinson, that the future access framework is intended to build on, rather than replace, many of the mechanisms familiar to heritage and charter operators today. I will not repeat some of the statistics I have previously used about the relative success of the present system for them, even though, as he says, it is not really provided for in any of the existing arrangements. I was delighted to speak with the noble Lord yesterday, together with my noble friend Lord Faulkner, about how to ensure that heritage and charter operators can obtain the confidence they need through a specific response to the access and use policy. If either or both of the noble Lords choose to respond to the access and use policy in the terms we discussed yesterday, I would be delighted to write and support that.
There is a significant overlap between some of the duties set out in Amendment 226 and the duties that the Bill already applies to GBR under Clause 18. The Bill already requires GBR to consider passengers, disabled passengers, freight certainty for businesses, social and economic factors, the environment and cost when carrying out all its access activities. I therefore do not think that a separate duplicative set of duties for access is useful.
On Amendment 224 from the noble Lord, Lord Lansley, sections 2.22 and 2.23 of the access and use policy are clear that GBR must allocate capacity in a fair, transparent and non-discriminatory way. I hope that is helpful.
The noble Lord, Lord Young, raised two points, one of which was about the powers of the CMA. This Bill does not affect the CMA’s powers at all—it retains the power to intervene. The ORR’s powers in this respect are not altered by the Bill; only its actual role on access is.
The noble Lord, Lord Young, made some points about Clause 63 and “must”, which the noble Lords, Lord Harper and Lord Lansley, also raised. It is worth saying that GBR cannot reserve capacity for future use in a way that contradicts its infrastructure capacity plan, which will already have considered the extent to which an open access operator could provide services that better use the infrastructure. Clause 63 is, in our view, not for self-preferencing. It is designed to ensure that funded services are delivered. But I will reflect further on the points that the noble Lord, Lord Young, made, because I would like to read what he said very carefully in Hansard. I want to be clear about my response to it, rather than speaking now, so that we have the definition and clarity that we seek.