L

Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 21 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

My answer to the noble Lord is that, in my view, the construction of this Bill precisely recognises the current use of the railway. The distinction between Clauses 60 and 63, and the clarity that I am seeking to bring to the limited circumstances of Clause 63, are designed to show that, given the number of users of the railway, and the precious nature and cost of the infrastructure, there is a job to do to use it in the best way. This is separate from the job that Clause 63 seeks to do, which is to make sure that GBR operates what the Secretary of State pays it to operate. We have never intended Clause 63 to say anything other than that. This is worth saying, because there might be future circumstances in which GBR prefers, financially, not to operate literally all the services that the Secretary of State is paying it to operate—but it has to. That is my point. However, I echo the point that I made earlier, which is that I would like to reflect on this debate after we have had it, because I want to make sure that the Bill that we bring to the next stages is as clear as it can be about what we are doing here. I hope that noble Lords have noticed that, in particular, we recognise the current users of the railway, whoever they are, and that we are seeking to make sure that they have as much clarity for the future as possible, because they provide some important services themselves. With Amendments 223 and 227, the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, is basically seeking to reinstate the present access and management regulations. He will not be surprised to learn that it is the existence of the current regulations, which prevent the integration of train and track and the best use of the infrastructure, that we are seeking to change. The three-month parliamentary laying-in period in Amendment 227 would create a significant operational and financial risk to the railway. Unnecessary delays will not be welcomed by either freight or open access operators, both of which rely on timely access decisions. It is important to recognise the nature of the access and use policy: it is a technical industry document designed to provide a fair and transparent process through which operators can apply for access. It sets out matters such as timescales, the information that applicants must provide and the way in which GBR will assess applications in line with its statutory responsibilities. It is therefore completely right that it is an industry-led and expert-led document, rather than one that requires ministerial or parliamentary scrutiny. I urge the noble Lord not to press those amendments. I turn to Amendments 251 and 251A. We have already seen that the consultation on the draft access and use policy has been developed closely with, and welcomed by, the industry. I draw noble Lords’ attention to paragraph 1.3 of the document, which provides a list of parties that GBR will consult before making changes to the AUP. This explicitly includes parties that hold track access contracts and those that are registered with GBR as prospective applicants. That is to ensure that existing and prospective open access freight and heritage operators are all able to feed in their views. Clause 66 requires consultation in relation not only to the AUP but to the preparation and revision of the working timetable under Clause 61. That ensures a transparent and consultative process, without requiring long lists of names. I hope that reassures the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, and my noble friend Lord Berkeley that they do not need to press their amendments. I turn to Amendment 252 in my name. As I mentioned, Network Rail has now launched the access and use policy consultation, working in close collaboration with the railway industry and devolved Governments, ahead of the establishment of GBR. As I said, this has been welcomed by people across the sector who are keen to see this as soon as possible. The Government’s intention has always been that GBR, once established, should be able to rely upon Network Rail’s consultation on the AUP. To support that objective, we sought to include a provision in the Bill. However, following further legal analysis, it has become clear that a small but important technical correction is required to enable GBR to treat the consultation undertaken by Network Rail as having been carried out by GBR. This amendment gives effect to that original policy intention. Without it, there would be practical implications for the industry, including the need to participate in a wasteful repeat of the consultation process. It would also prolong uncertainty for operators. Given that this is simply a technical change to correct a mistake in the drafting, I hope the Committee will agree with this amendment today. Finally, in response to the noble Lord, Lord Harper, the regulation of international services through the Channel Tunnel is not affected by this legislation. My noble friend Lord Berkeley spoke to various amendments, but he will find that they are all in the next group and I will respond to them then. Of course, I am grateful to my noble friend Lord Tunnicliffe for his view, and I am more than happy to discuss this further, having reflected on the discussion that we have had today on this group and that we will have on other groups.

More from Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.