L

Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 21 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I am grateful to my noble friend Lord Faulkner for supporting the premise that we need a directing mind for the railway. I hope I will not prolong the previous discussion but will say only this: only GBR, as the principal operator, has the expertise to decide how best to use the infrastructure and transfer that into a plan for its better enhancement. We have not had that for 30 years, which has resulted in parts of the railway being far too full—and being unable to support any further trains, whoever operates them—and a sizeable amount of money going to schemes that are perfectly welcome but are a suboptimal use of funding. I will try not to repeat the opening statement I made, which the Committee was patient enough to listen to, other than to say that this is, again, about the infrastructure capacity plan and Clause 60. The noble Lord, Lord Harper, suggested that the list set out in Clause 60 might somehow be in some particular order. All I would say is that you cannot refer to other operators until you have referred to the principal operator of passenger services, so there is some logic in it, but we will also clarify in the Explanatory Notes that the list is not in any preference order. I am as keen as other people to show that this process is designed to be fair and open. I also think, for what it is worth, that, were the years of expertise in the ORR to have been shown to be useful, they were certainly seriously damaged by the 0700 Manchester Piccadilly to Euston experience. The regulator was definitive that it was not capable of being run, despite the fact that its operator and the infrastructure owner said it should be. It is running today, and it runs perfectly satisfactorily. From time to time, I look to see whether it runs to time, and it does, because it would have run anyway. That is the sort of thing we are trying to stop here. I will be brief on Amendment 230 from the noble Lord, Lord Parkinson. He has made his case well. For the avoidance of doubt and for the record, I think the reference in Clause 60 to other railway passenger services refers to all non-GBR services that carry passengers, including those of charter and heritage services and those on the main line, to the degree that they are on the main line. Because he referred to it and because I know there is a particular worry in that direction, I say to him that I am determined that operators who have regular train paths be dealt with in the same way in Clause 60 as others. They are operating them because they provide a public service and a purpose, and to some extent they provide income to heritage railways, and I am absolutely determined that they should continue, which is why it is referred to in that way. But, as I said, there is something more to be said about all that in the AUP. The clearer his letter is, the more delighted I will be to support it.

More from Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.