L

Lord Young of Cookham (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 21 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I will intervene briefly on this group of amendments, which deals with Clause 64 on the charging scheme. Behind my noble friend Lord Moylan’s amendments and the concerns we have just heard from the noble Lord, Lord Berkeley, is a concern that open access and freight operators might be, in effect, priced out by GBR deciding on an access charge that is beyond their capacity to pay. It is in connection with that that I will quote very briefly from a letter that the Secretary of State for Transport wrote to the ORR on 6 January 2025. It underlines the concerns that my noble friend expressed: that open-access operators might be discouraged by the impact on the taxpayer. The Secretary of State wrote: “We need to be mindful of the impacts of Open Access such as the level of revenue they can abstract from contracted services and the associated implications for passengers and taxpayers”. I suspect that that letter was prompted by the Treasury, because the loss of revenue from GBR’s passenger services will have a direct impact on the subsidy that GBR gets from the Treasury. Before we get to the question of what the access charge should be, at the moment there is a process—I cannot find any reference to it in the legislation—which is carried out by the ORR and is called the abstraction rate. If you are an open access operator and want to operate a new service, you have to demonstrate that no less than 70% of the revenue that you will get comes from an existing operator. In other words, you have to show that your service will increase the overall passenger numbers by 30%. Only if you overcome that hurdle do you come to the next one, which deals with the access charges. At Second Reading, I asked the Minister whether they had any plans to change the abstraction rate—because if you tweak the abstraction rate you do not even get to Clause 64, as far as I understand it, which is what your access charge would be. I had a very helpful meeting with the Minister last week, where we discussed the abstraction rate. The information that I got from officials was that they were moving slightly away from a simple, crude abstraction rate to a more broadly based formula that looked at the abstraction rate as well as what was described as social factors. In one aspect, that might be helpful to the open access operator, because there might be social reasons for agreeing to the application that are not entirely captured by the abstraction rate. The question I have for the Minister on this is, first, will there still be an abstraction rate, and are there any plans on the part of GBR to change it? Secondly, can we have slightly more detail on the formula that will be used, which, as I understand it, complements or perhaps replaces the abstraction rate, so we have a clearer idea of the criteria that will be used? Finally, why is there no reference at all in any of this legislation to the abstraction rate, which is a crucial factor in determining whether an open access operator can succeed?

More from Lord Young of Cookham (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.