L

Lord Harper (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 21 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

It is a fair question. People listening to this from outside might ask, given that GBR runs the infrastructure and services, what the point is of one bit of the business charging another bit. However, if you are going to make economically rational decisions, it is quite important that the passenger services part of GBR, which makes decisions about which services to run, where there is demand for those services and what people are prepared to pay for them, uses the same cost basis—in other words, access to the valuable infrastructure. The Minister has said on many occasions that the infrastructure is expensive—it is—and that it is important that it is used in the most economically beneficial way. That can be done only with proper pricing and charging. As soon as you start saying that GBR passenger services does not have to pay for access and that it is not being treated on the same basis, you will lose the transparency and the ability to make those rational economic decisions. That is the bit that I am missing. If this is not set up properly, we will end up making bad economic decisions, which is bad for the public, because all those costs land on the taxpayer. There are two other problems. I will finish after those. First, the Minister talked about the importance of investment in producing infrastructure. That is right but, given that capital is limited, that capacity investment must be in the bits of infrastructure that will deliver the best return for the taxpayer. That means that you need to charge for it properly. Secondly, I am not yet clear to what extent GBR will publish its financial information. Some of that will be commercially confidential, as it will operate in a competitive market. However, as this service is being considerably subsidised by the taxpayer, I would expect as much information as possible to be published. Given that Ministers come under enormous pressure to preserve existing services and deliver new services, to have that sensible conversation with both elected representatives and the public, you have to be able to demonstrate the benefit of the service and how much it costs to deliver. Without that level of transparency and without charging for the infrastructure, I do not see how you will be able to do so.

More from Lord Harper (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.