L

Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 21 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

Of course. I try to copy all my letters to all noble Lords. I will write to say how it applies today and how it will apply in the future. I turn to Amendment 240, on charges when capacity is not utilised. Clause 64 does not force GBR to levy charges whenever a service fails to operate. Rather, it requires GBR to set out transparently how such circumstances would be treated within its charging framework. Whether a charge is applied in any given case will remain a matter requiring judgment and discretion. The ability to consider charges for unused capacity already exists within the current legislative framework. Although it is not currently actively used, we believe that it is important to retain this capability as GBR brings together responsibility for access and charging decisions. With such finite capacity on the network, it is important, when operators are granted access, that they make a reasonable effort to make use of it and are disincentivised from simply holding on to capacity. Therefore, the ability to levy a reservation charge is a useful tool to drive the right behaviours and incentives on the network, ensuring that best use is made of capacity and that operators remain accountable for providing the services they previously agreed to deliver. Having said that, GBR will need to take into consideration divergent industry operating models, such as freight, which is market driven and therefore has less assurances on services. On that basis, GBR would, of course, need to consider its duties to promote freight growth before ever levying such a charge. Alternatively, however, the concept of one freight operator preventing another freight operator being given those rights instead is equally detrimental to freight growth. In today’s framework, when a freight operator holds on to rights that it is not using, Network Rail finds it extremely challenging to incentivise that operator to release that path so that it can reallocate the rights to another freight operator that does have business—through a contract with a freight customer—to use the path as intended. However, with GBR as the directing mind, there is an opportunity to utilise reservation charges in a useful way to compliment best use while protecting and promoting the growth of the freight sector. Network Rail analysis of some key freight markets suggests that just over two-thirds of useable freight paths in the timetable are actually utilised, though this varies substantially by commodity, location and market conditions. That is not to say that the remaining paths are not needed or that they should all be subject to reservation charges. Freight demand is not constant, and the origins and destinations of traffic vary according to customer needs. We would never expect anything approaching 100% utilisation.

More from Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.