L

Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 21 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

My Lords, first, I apologise that the letter that I sent to the noble Lord, Lord Lansley, this morning was not circulated to other noble Lords. That was my omission. I was very keen to get it out this morning. I will ensure that it is circulated to noble Lords as soon as possible. I have made it my business to make sure that all the correspondence that I have sent to individual noble Lords on this has been circulated to others, but we will check to make sure that there is no correspondence to one noble Lord that is not copied to everybody else. I do apologise for that. There are things to agree on in this debate. The Bill must provide a robust route for operators to appeal against GBR’s decisions. My concern, which noble Lords will understand, is that we do not position the appeal body, the ORR, as a second, parallel decision-maker that can impose its own judgments in preference to GBR’s. It does not have end-to-end route and network expertise. I was going to say that we can see the results of having too many decision-makers every day. I am sorry to say that the circumstances described just now by the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, are another example of fragmented decision-making on the railway in circumstances where GBR thinking about its wider duties to passengers would have come to a different decision on its own. I regret not having known about this at the time. Otherwise, I might have done something about it well before it got to that stage. It demonstrates why the railway needs to be managed by a body that has wider considerations for passengers and the economy. At the noble Baroness said, if the trains had been bought with public money, it would be ludicrous. Having said that, judicial review principles are a well-established mechanism for holding public bodies to account. A clear example of that is in the High Court: when the High Court reviews decisions made by government departments or regulators, it focuses on whether the decision was made lawfully and fairly, rather than replacing it with its own judgment. These principles afford the decision-maker appropriate latitude to make informed judgments, to weigh different considerations against each other and to reach a balanced decision, but they also safeguard against decisions that are unreasonable or irrational, fail to take proper account of relevant statutory duties, are inconsistent with its own published policies, processes and criteria, or are otherwise unlawful. That is the standard to which GBR should be held. GBR must be the decision-maker on access, and the ORR should be there to ensure that GBR is reasonable, rational and consistent with its duties and policies. The Bill deliberately requires the ORR to apply judicial review principles and the amendments would, as we have discussed, widen the process and make it merits based.

More from Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.