Contribution
I thank the noble Lord for that intervention. He will know—or I hope he knows—that we discussed at some length what he is talking about. I agree with him about not double-guessing GBR as it needs to take its decisions, but I will go away and further consider what he and others have said in the light of this discussion. We have had an interesting discussion with a number of different views, and the thing that chimes with me most is his understanding that GBR has to make these decisions, because somebody has to be in charge of the network.
I turn to Amendments 259 and 262. I note that both noble Lords seek to question why the ORR can quash and replace some decisions but not others. The distinction in the Bill is deliberate. The appropriate remedy reflects the different nature of the matters or decisions under appeal. When an appeal concerns policies or strategic documents, such as GBR’s access and use policy, the ORR can remit decisions to GBR for reconsideration. The ORR may also give legally binding directions as to that reconsideration, which GBR must follow. Those documents involve complex and interconnected judgments about the operation and use of the railway, in which many factors apply, and where there is often more than one acceptable answer. The interconnected nature of the policies and processes set out in these documents also means that quashing a single element in isolation will often not make sense.
It is therefore right that GBR reconsiders the provision in light of the appeal and the ORR’s directions. This approach also reflects that it is GBR, not the ORR, which has the expertise and whole-network view, and is therefore able to take these decisions in the best interests of all railway users and its wider duties. This ensures that the issue identified on appeal is addressed, while preserving GBR’s responsibility for the resulting strategic judgment. This will also enable GBR to more effectively learn from its mistakes. For specific operational decisions, such as refusing an application for a train movement to be added to the working timetable, the Bill goes further. In those cases, the ORR may quash all or part of the decision and send it back to GBR for reconsideration, with directions. But in some limited circumstances, the ORR can substitute its own decision.
It may be helpful to think of this like marking somebody’s homework. GBR is writing its homework by making the decision, then the ORR marks that homework. The ORR uses GBR’s legal duties, its published processes and policies and so on, as its marking scheme. Some decisions might only have one possible correct answer, like a maths problem; in those cases, the ORR could immediately substitute the correct answer in place of GBR’s incorrect one. But, for much of GBR’s homework, there will be no single right or wrong answer. GBR will need to exercise significant judgment. In those cases, it will be for the ORR to check GBR’s workings and ask whether GBR got to its decision in a rational and reasonable way. If it did not, the ORR can send the homework back to GBR, with appropriate feedback, and tell it to try again. Giving the ORR a broader discretion to substitute its own judgment would blur responsibility and undermine GBR’s role as the single directing mind. GBR must have the space to apply its end-to-end operational knowledge to optimise best use of the network.
Likewise, if we were to go the other way and remove the option for the ORR to substitute its own decision in these specific circumstances, the matter would have to go back to GBR even when there would have been only one lawful decision that GBR could have reached. This would add an unnecessary further step, with associated time and complexity for the parties involved. The limited substitution power therefore supports an efficient and proportionate appeals process without giving the ORR a general power to take decisions in GBR’s place. It preserves the balance at the heart of the framework: GBR remains responsible for decision-making, while the ORR provides effective independent oversight. This process clearly provides protection for operators, and I therefore urge the noble Lord to withdraw the amendment.