L

Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 21 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

I will take the noble Lord’s question away and answer it in writing. This time, I will of course copy it to everybody. On Amendments 263 and 264, the clear intention of the framework is to provide a proportionate and accessible route of appeal to the ORR, which would avoid the time, complexity and expense associated with court proceedings. The Government also intend that the ORR will set its own practice and procedure for its appeals process, engaging with industry as it does so. The Secretary of State’s regulation-making power does not interfere with the ORR procedure; instead, it enables provision to be made, where necessary, about steps that must be taken before an appeal can be brought and in relation to fees and time limits. The power does not give the Secretary of State a role in determining individual appeals, which will remain the ORR’s responsibility. The regulation-making power is intended as a fallback should the appeals process become unworkable or operational changes become necessary. For example, we do not think that it would be appropriate for the ORR to set its own fees; any proposal to charge fees ought to be subject to ministerial and parliamentary scrutiny. These powers are not intended to be exercised routinely, but could be useful if the ORR proposed to make changes, such as introducing fees, that ought to be subject to wider scrutiny. The power can be exercised only after consultation with the ORR and any other persons the Secretary of State considers appropriate. That provision is deliberately flexible and has been included to enable consultation with stakeholders, including open access operators where relevant, without creating an unnecessarily rigid statutory list. On Amendment 265, to be clear, before issuing, revising or replacing its appeals practice and procedure, the ORR must consult any other persons it considers appropriate, in addition to any named statutory consultees. This deliberately gives the ORR flexibility to consult relevant stakeholders, including open access operators, without creating an inflexible and unwieldy statutory list. Importantly, engagement on the ORR’s future appeals process and procedure is already happening. The ORR published its appeals process discussion document in December last year and sought early views from the industry on its emerging approach. This included its thinking on indicative time limits for when an appeal may be brought and appeal windows. Open access operators have therefore already contributed to the development of the ORR’s emerging appeals process and will have further opportunity to do so through the ORR’s formal consultation following Royal Assent. I therefore urge the noble Lords not to press their amendments.

More from Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.