Contribution
My Lords, I add my thanks to the noble Lord, Lord Anderson of Ipswich, for securing this fascinating debate on the proposals for a written constitution and for his very thought-provoking introduction. This is a vast and complex subject that has been long debated, including in your Lordships’ House.
We have heard many interesting contributions from across the House. Without picking out any particular favourites—but I am going to—I particularly enjoyed the contribution by my noble friend Lord Griffiths of Burry Port, which was both entertaining and fascinating, and also demonstrated some of the challenges we face in this area of debate.
The Government warmly welcome the opportunity to debate these issues in Parliament. As the noble Lord, Lord Anderson, made clear, this is of interest well beyond this Chamber, including among students, not least those taught by my amazing noble friend Lord Murphy of Torfaen. I think it was the noble Lord, Lord Hannay of Chiswick, who said that a written constitution would make teaching students easier, which is one argument in favour of a written constitution, perhaps—though not necessarily a defining one.
It was helpful to hear alternative views put forward to noble Lords by the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett of Manor Castle, although I did not necessarily agree with everything she said. It was also interesting to hear the account from the noble Lord, Lord Kerr of Kinlochard, of a failed attempt to write a constitution for the EU. I welcome the alternative view of the noble Lord, Lord Pack, in his support for a written constitution, which significantly balanced the debate.
As noble Lords are clearly aware, our constitutional system is somewhat unusual. Noble Lords, including the noble and learned Lord, Lord Mance, noted that it is uncodified. As my noble friend Lord Stansgate said, it is not in one document but is dispersed across many documents and sources. As the noble and learned Lord, Lord Burnett of Maldon, said, it has evolved over time and is made up of conventions, statutes, judicial decisions, principles and practices. As the noble Baroness, Lady Finn, said in her remarks, it relies more on balances and checks.
Like every constitution, it is imperfect. However, it is also flexible and adaptable. This is a core feature of our constitution and it has served us well, as many noble Lords, including the noble Lord, Lord Howard of Lympne, made clear. It is not written down in a single place, yet it exists. I agree with my noble friend Lord Murphy that it is strong. I also agree that a written constitution does not in itself necessarily confer protection. As the noble Lord, Lord Howard, made clear, totalitarian regimes would not be deterred by a written constitution per se. As the noble and learned Lord, Lord Burnett, said, all written constitutions are vulnerable to bad actors. The example given by the noble Baroness, Lady Manningham-Buller, of 1930s Germany demonstrates this powerfully, as did many other examples given today.
It is the very features of the UK constitution that mean it is not frozen in aspic, and nor should it be if we want a political system that delivers for everyone. The noble Baroness, Lady Prashar, mentioned the need for trust and for us to rebuild it, and this is key. The Government’s priority is a politics that works for all people in all places, not just some people in some places. We are beginning the work of shifting power and resources away from Whitehall, as set out in the Rewiring the State Cabinet statement of 31 July. We have already launched the biggest transfer of power from Westminster in a generation. That includes the largest package of financial powers ever offered to English mayors, with a retained share of income tax revenues for the first time. We will replace the current model of consultation by default with new and modern forms of public participation.
The noble Lord, Lord Pack, mentioned electoral reform. As the Prime Minister has announced, the Government intend to establish a new national commission on electoral reform, and he invited all political parties to be part of this work. We want everyone’s vote to count and everyone’s voice to be heard. The Government are not afraid of going further and, where there is a case for doing so, codifying elements of our constitutional arrangements.
The noble Baroness, Lady D’Souza, referred to the IfG recommendation of a new Joint Committee on the constitution. The establishment of a Joint Committee is clearly a matter for Parliament rather than government. I note that the Lords Constitution Committee is already undertaking an important inquiry into the UK’s constitutional safeguards, as mentioned by a number of noble Lords, and I look forward to reading the findings of that inquiry in due course.
As the noble Lord, Lord Anderson, the noble and learned Lord, Lord Mance, and my noble friend Lord Stansgate highlighted, the Government are currently drafting an update to the Cabinet Manual. The Cabinet Manual, as noble Lords will be aware, serves as an authoritative guide to the UK’s constitutional arrangements. It is the Executive’s view on the processes and rules around the operation of government, including the formation of a Government following an election. The Cabinet Manual is not intended to be a written constitution but acts as a practical document to help Ministers, officials and the public understand how government works and its interaction with other parts of the constitution. It was first published in 2011, and it has become significantly out of date, most notably, as has been noted during today’s debate, in its descriptions of the UK’s relationship with the EU, of general elections and of the devolution settlement. An update will therefore restore the manual’s status as an authoritative guide. The Government will seek feedback from parliamentary Select Committees on proposed revisions. This is intended to be a meaningful opportunity for MPs and Peers to support the updating process so that the manual continues to be a non-party-political document that provides a record of fact.
My noble friend Lord Stansgate asked about progress and when the work was likely to come to a conclusion. I am pleased to be able to confirm to noble Lords that the update to the manual is well under way, and we intend to publish the updated manual early next year.
The noble Lord, Lord Anderson, asked for the Government’s view on a written constitution. The Government welcome feedback, continued discussion and debates, such as the one we are having today, on the next steps on constitutional reform. That is different to converting the UK’s uncodified constitutional arrangements into a single written document for its own sake. The noble and learned Lord, Lord Boyd, wisely cautioned us to consider the time and effort it would take to create a codified constitution, and the work of the noble Lord, Lord Anderson, on this subject shows that constitutional reform is not a straightforward subject, and there are steps well short of a written constitution that we can consider.
As time goes on, as society changes and as new issues emerge, constitutional arrangements need to adapt accordingly. Indeed, one of the main issues with written constitutions is that they can become out of date very quickly, as the procedures and rules for amending them may often be cumbersome and difficult to satisfy.
Before I conclude, there are a couple of other points I wish to cover. A number of noble Lords, including the noble Lords, Lord Anderson and Lord Carter of Haslemere, and the noble and learned Lords, Lord Burnett and Lord Boyd, referred to the role of the judiciary. We believe and are very clear that it is important that we have an independent judiciary. During the debate, the risk of creating an overpowerful judiciary under a written constitution was also noted, not least by the noble Lord, Lord Howard. An independent judiciary is, however, a cornerstone of our constitutional arrangements.
The noble Lord, Lord Kakkar, the noble Baroness, Lady Finn, and others referred to parliamentary sovereignty. I agree with the noble Lord, Lord Kakkar, on the importance of parliamentary sovereignty as a central tenet of our constitutional arrangements.
In conclusion, I once more thank the noble Lord, Lord Anderson, for leading a very thought-provoking discussion on our constitutional arrangements. As the noble Lord, Lord Pack, said, it was timely, given what a testing time we live in. This Government’s priority is to establish a politics that works for all people in all places, not some people in some places. We are serious about constitutional reform, and we will take bold steps where there is a case to do so.