L

Lord Hannan of Kingsclere (Non-Afl)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 23 October 2026

Debate

House of Lords (Alternative Second Chamber) Bill [HL]

Contribution

My Lords, I add my voice to the swelling paean of praise for the noble Baroness, Lady Smith of Llanfaes. Peers on all sides have commended her for her courage, which is true but also very telling. It presupposes that she knew that her Bill would be unpopular here, which the debate has indeed borne out, yet it is worth reminding ourselves that almost all the political parties are in favour of changing the existing composition of the upper House. It is one of the paradoxes of our system. Everyone is in favour of it on paper, yet somehow it never becomes a proposal. I remember that, when I was still a Conservative, I asked the then party leader, David Cameron, when he was still in opposition, whether he would get around to his technical manifesto commitment to a different upper House. He said, “Yes, that will be a fourth-term issue for us”. That has been the approach of all parties. I understand it. I am enough of a small-c conservative to get the argument that if you do not need to change, you do not change. None the less, it is based on shaky foundations. The basic argument against reform of this place, which we heard very eloquently expressed just now by the noble Lord, Lord Jackson of Peterborough, and which was flagged up by the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett, is the primacy of the House of Commons. We are told that if there were any elected element in this House, it would be intolerable and would create constitutional gridlock. The noble Baroness, Lady O’Grady, points out that every other country in Europe has an elected element in its upper Chamber, and that does not lead to constant constitutional gridlock—other than sometimes in Belgium, where I lived for a bit. In other places it works remarkably well, because you can define the function of an upper House, set out its powers and then consider its composition. Form follows function. Therefore, you could set out for this House to have strong powers of delay, block and veto, but weak powers of initiation, for example. Whatever it was you then decided on, you could draw up a plan for composition accordingly. On the “form follows function” basis, of all the systems that we could have, the one where the Executive appoint one of the two legislative Chambers is the weakest. I will not get into what alternatives there are. We have heard loads of them. You could have a single long non-renewable term, you could have it elected through a different voting system, you could have the Bundesrat or regional system that Gordon Brown’s proposal was getting towards, or you could have it chosen by lot, like a jury. Almost any of them would be better than having the Executive appointing half the legislature. It is worth reminding ourselves of what these Parliaments are for. If you look between the windows up there, you will see these rather hunky medieval figures in chainmail. They represent the bishops and barons who forced King John to agree to the great charter. They are put there for a reason: to remind us of the primary purpose of this Chamber, which is not to legislate, not to sit on committees, not to make speeches and not even to represent people; it is to prevent the Executive from exceeding their powers. The conciliar form of government by bishops and barons that we had in this country from 1215 onwards was primarily about ensuring that even the King had to obey the law like everybody else. Everything else we do is secondary; everything else is a nice bonus. We are here to stop the Government breaking the rules or exceeding their powers. Therefore, you have to say: is there any stranger way of composing the upper House than allowing that Government to nominate its Members? I realise that this is going to be unpopular here, because all noble Lords are beneficiaries of that system. None the less, would anyone, from first principles, try to argue for that system? I am sure noble Lords are bursting to tell me that if we went down the road of defining the functions of this House, we would be opening the door to a written constitution, and that all these other chambers that the noble Baroness, Lady O’Grady, alluded to have some kind of supreme court and some kind of division of powers laid out on paper. As we were reminded by the noble Lord, Lord Anderson of Ipswich, at the end of the debate yesterday, in this country we have been talking about whether there should be some codification of our constitution for at least 400 years. It is nice to see that the noble Baroness, Lady Twycross, who was responding at the very end yesterday, is back in her place so early this morning. This is a very old debate. A number of anomalies have crept in, of which this Chamber is not the foremost. There are real questions over how the devolution settlement is working; if we had been able to foresee where we are now in 1998, I wonder whether we would have done it in the way we have. There are real issues about the way our voting system—designed, and extremely effective, when there were two parties—is creaking under the weight of a five-party system. Above all, there are issues about the growth of judicial review and the power of the Supreme Court that were never foreseen at the time. There is a case for looking at all these things in the round, through the tried and tested form of a royal commission. I do not want to anticipate where it would go; all I am saying is that it is no longer viable to say that there should be no change or reform. Perhaps the greatest statement of Toryism spoken in Parliament was from the second Viscount Falkland, who famously said: “When it is not necessary to change, it is necessary not to change”. It is often forgotten that he was talking about the composition of Parliament—specifically, about whether bishops should sit in the House of Lords. It was very inspiring conservative and Tory sentiment, but it led to ruin; it was followed by a civil war, then a military dictatorship. I prefer Edmund Burke’s approach, when he said: “A State without the means of some change is without the means of its conservation”.

More from Lord Hannan of Kingsclere (Non-Afl)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.