L

Lord Hannan of Kingsclere (Non-Afl)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 29 October 2026

Debate

Personal Independence Payment and Disability Benefits: Implementation and Impact

Contribution

My Lords, I will start with some statistics, some raw numbers that are sobering, alarming, and, in their way, shaming. Some 30,000 people every day are signing on for long-term invalidity and incapacity benefits. The largest rise, incredibly in every sense, is among people aged between 25 and 34, the cohort just above that identified by the noble Lord, Lord Willetts. Some 60,000 people every year go straight from university on to long-term sickness benefits. Some 25% of people—25% of adults—identify as disabled, which suggests to me that the definition that at least some of them are using is very far from the definition traditionally understood. Then, of course, there is the cost. We heard from the noble Baroness, Lady Jenkin, that 3.4 million people are claiming this benefit. That is, on the Government’s own figures, supposed to rise to 4.1 million by the end of this Parliament. Why is this happening? Part of the answer was the lockdown, which introduced a lot of working people who up until then had never really claimed anything from the Government to a different way of living. We saw a large move away from employment and into other kinds of grants and benefits all over the world. But, for some reason, whereas in most western countries, and almost every other European country, that spike was reversed when the lockdown ended from the end of 2021, in this country, a lot of it has remained institutionalised. The huge improvements that were made between 2010 and 2020 in reducing the number of people who were out of work permanently were reversed almost overnight. Why did that happen? As Warren Buffett’s right-hand man, Charlie Munger, used to say, “Show me the incentive and I’ll show you the outcome”. We just heard the incentives very ably adumbrated by the noble Lord, Lord Young of Cookham. If you can work and earn slightly more, but almost the same as you would be getting without doing anything—and the noble Lord, Lord Young, was too generous or polite to point out that, of course, within those benefits you could also be doing some side hustling which would push you over the limit—some people are going to follow the rational incentive, and we can hardly blame them. The real tragedy here is not so much for the taxpayer as for the people who get trapped in a life of low income and low expectations. None of what I have said should be remotely controversial. Indeed, I think there is a cross-party consensus that the system needs to be tightened up. There was an attempt in another place to tighten up the system, and the reason that attempt failed and ended up extending some of the claims that were opened bears scrutiny. I remember talking to a Labour MP, a friend of mine, who showed me on her phone what the WhatsApp groups of some Labour MPs were saying. In particular, they were circulating a survey by a disability charity that tabulated by constituency the number of PIP claimants and showed in how many constituencies the number of claimants was bigger than the MP’s majority. Those of your Lordships who have served in another place will know that tends to concentrate the minds of parliamentarians. But we are doing people no favours if we shy away from reform. We are not just encouraging an atmosphere where mental health conditions become normalised; we almost serve as a vector for more of them. I have noticed that this rise in mental health conditions has led to an extraordinary change in language among people. When did you last hear somebody under the age of 30 saying “I am unhappy” rather than “I am depressed”, which is almost always their go-to adjective? When did you last hear them saying, “This makes me nervous” rather than “This is giving me anxiety”? “This is giving me PTSD” is one I hear from a lot of my children’s friends. I say, “No, that’s really not PTSD. Someone said something mean to you; it is not quite the same thing”. But as we normalise the medicalisation of language, it is no surprise that people genuinely think they are succumbing to these conditions. I read that so many anti-depressants are being flushed into our sewage system that it is beginning to affect the fish in the channel. It must be true, because I read it in the Daily Mail. Are we doing anybody any favours, other than those MPs worried about their majorities, when we shy away from tackling these conditions? I agree very much with what the noble Baroness, Lady Jenkin, said at the beginning: what is the rationale for having these personal independence payments? The clue is in the name: they are to deal with the additional costs that come from a disability. If, by disability, we understand what was traditionally understood—somebody who has a physical impairment—then there might be costs: they might need to adjust access to their house, there would be transport difficulties and there might be care costs. How does somebody who has anxiety or depression have a more expensive lifestyle than somebody who is unemployed but does not have those conditions? I do not mean for a moment to belittle those very unpleasant conditions, but it does not follow, unpleasant as they are, that they lead to a more expensive lifestyle. It is quite extraordinary that, as the definition of disability has expanded, we have not adjusted its financial consequences. Perhaps the key point is this: for those who really suffer from anxiety, depression or related mental health conditions, are we helping them when we encourage them to stay home taking pills? When we give benefits payments that discourage people from working, we cut them off from the things that are usually the surest route—not in every single case—towards recovery. We all need to be needed. We all need to have others relying on us. Taking people out of employment takes that very real psychological prop away and often worsens the condition that we are purporting to care about. I hope that we will have the courage and the vision properly to tackle this growing problem: a problem for the economy of the nation, yes, but, much more gravely, for that growing number of millions of our fellow citizens who are trapped in these lifestyles. Show me the incentive, and I will show you the outcome. The incentive for us should be to do the right thing by those of our fellow citizens who have been put in this situation, and to do the right thing by our own duty as parliamentarians.

More from Lord Hannan of Kingsclere (Non-Afl)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.