Contribution
My Lords, I would like to congratulate my noble friend Lord Weir of Ballyholme on introducing this Motion and on the manner in which he introduced it. It is very rare that we get second chances. Providence has provided us with one here, and I really hope that Ministers will look impartially at the opportunity before them.
I am going to canter over, very briefly, some of the history of how we got here. The islands were uninhabited until 1783, when they were taken by France, which populated them with an enslaved population brought mainly from east Africa. They were then taken from the French in the Napoleonic Wars in 1810—an episode fictionalised in the Aubrey/Maturin novels by Patrick O’Brian, where Jack Aubrey is given the wonderful line that it strikes him as absurd and unnatural that islands should not be British.
In 1814, the islands were then ceded as part of the general movement of territories following the Congress of Vienna, and there things stayed. Britain manumitted the slave population. The territory was administered from Mauritius only in the sense that it was too small to maintain an administrative seat and therefore had its administration in Mauritius in the same way that Aden had its administration in India. It would be a very strange and bizarre thing if that became the basis of sovereignty claims around the world.
Fast forward to 1965, when Britain is decolonising, there is some dispute within Mauritius about not wanting to be decolonised. One of the Mauritian political parties is arguing that Mauritius should instead have representation in another place and be an integral part of the UK in the same manner as the DOM-TOMs of France, but Britain pushes ahead with the decolonisation, maintaining sovereignty over the British Indian Ocean Territory.
To put the issue beyond doubt, Mauritius trousers what was in those days a very large sum of money permanently to renounce any claim it might have to the sovereignty of the archipelago. The then Prime Minister was later asked in a Mauritian parliamentary committee whether he was pressured. He said no. He was very happy to take the money. He said this is a portion of our territory which is very far from here and which we have never visited. He might have added that it was historically and ethnically different—its population, as it were, broadly having come from the West rather than from the East. There was very little sense of awareness, let alone of claim, of this being a similar population.
There we can leave things until, perhaps with an approximation to China going on in the early 20th century, until Mauritius gets together a posse of third-worldist judges and on the basis of a non-binding resolution of the UN General Assembly, gets another non-binding ruling that somehow this territory belongs, in defiance of the wishes of its people, to a country that had never owned it and that had until then shown no interest beyond the pecuniary interests that it had.
So, once again, I am going to say to the Minister and to other Ministers: take the off ramp. There is no good in pursuing this process. It is senseless militarily. We are imperilling a key base that commands four of the seven naval choke points. We are inviting unfriendly powers to take up positions in the surrounding archipelago. It makes no sense ecologically. We are giving away the most pristine maritime conservation zone in the world to a nation with a very poor record on biodiversity. It makes no sense democratically because the overwhelming majority of Chagossian people, those born on the islands and their descendants, are clear that they do not want to be Mauritians and that they want, as they have made clear over and over again, to return to their islands as British overseas subjects. Of course, it makes no sense financially. Good luck to any political party going into an election saying, “We are raising your taxes here so that they can cut their taxes in Mauritius”, which is indeed the boast being made by some Mauritian politicians.
How have we ended up in this place? I can best describe it as something one sees often with the Foreign Office: “Bridge on the River Kwai” syndrome. If you take as your starting assumption the absolute supremacy of any international tribunal, even when it issues non-binding resolutions, and even when, for all the reasons that we just heard from the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, its jurisdiction in this case is expressly excluded because of the military nature of the facility and because disputes between Commonwealth or ex-Commonwealth members are excluded from its jurisdiction, if you none the less are tearing around the world in your Matrix Chambers/Doughty Street way, looking for international tribunals to which to surrender, and this is your priority, then within those terms, the leaseback agreement had a certain ingenuity. It had a certain neatness, and it could be justified when there was pressure from the then US Administration to do it, and when there was pressure internally because of the obsession of the previous Prime Minister and the previous Attorney-General with international law.
However, as with the bridge on the River Kwai, this treaty was never primarily in the British national interest. It was only a response to a very specific circumstance, and that circumstance has now changed. The US Government have made it very clear that they do not want to go ahead with this treaty, and, rather in the manner of Alec Guinness in the movie, we still have officials trying to stick to the thing in which they had invested so much of their time and ingenuity. I hope that, even now, one of them will fall on the plunger and undo the folly because, in doing so, we would restore our relations with our closest ally, and we would save ourselves a great deal of money.
I have to say, not that it is any of my business, that the party opposite would be doing itself a great favour electorally. I cannot help noticing that at every stage, including today, the Labour Benches have been completely empty when we have been discussing this issue because Labour politicians, whether in this place or in another place, did not generally go into politics again to betray a poor, black, dispossessed population and hand a pristine maritime conservation zone to a country with a terrible record ecologically.
There is every reason to pull out while there is still time. Let me urge the Minister and all Ministers to take the win: take the off ramp.