L

Lord Murray of Blidworth (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 23 October 2026

Debate

British Sovereignty Protection (Chagos Islands) Bill [HL]

Contribution

My Lords, I, too, congratulate the noble Lord, Lord Weir, on advancing this eminently sensible and timely Bill before the House today. It is also a great privilege to follow my noble friend Lord Lilley and to inform the House that I am glad to say that he has given most of my speech, which means that I can greatly accelerate the remarks that I am going to make to the House today. The first point is that it is regrettable that we need to bring this Bill at all. It is perhaps a statement of the approach taken by the Government towards the support for the overseas territories that we have, sadly, to present this Bill in order to put a brake on the surrender of our own sovereign territory. But that is what it has come to. My noble friend Lord Lilley addressed the various legal shibboleths that the treaty was premised upon; in particular, he dealt carefully with the fact that the advisory judgment of the ICJ and the powers of UNCLOS mean that there cannot be any international court which can rule upon our sovereignty over those islands. There is one other legal issue that my noble friend did not touch on, and it is that which I ask directly to the Minister to answer. In the debates on the government Bill last Session, it was accepted by the Government that the state of Mauritius is a signatory to the Treaty of Pelindaba, which forbids the positioning of nuclear weapons on African soil. If the Chagos Islands become part of Mauritius, they will be covered by the operation of that treaty, and we know from many sources—not least from the speech given by the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Houghton, during the debates on that Bill—that the Americans routinely position nuclear weapons in the Chagos Islands. Indeed, there is some media reporting that they are stored there. On that basis, we have never had a satisfactory explanation from the Government, or indeed any explanation, as to how it is said that Mauritius under this agreement would agree to the continuance of the use of the base for the storage or transit of nuclear weapons. Accordingly, it seems to me that our American allies are going to be very hostile to this surrender of sovereignty, and the Government have so far just ignored this point. My question today to the Minister is: what do the Government say about Mauritius’s membership of the Treaty of Pelindaba in relation to the agreement that was reached? I very much hope that the Minister, being part of Mr Burnham’s Administration who have agreed to review the deal, will say that it does not matter because they are going to revise our view on this deal.

More from Lord Murray of Blidworth (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.