Contribution
My Lords, as at Second Reading, I declare my interest as a practising barrister. When I was a very junior barrister, I was a practitioner in the criminal courts, both in the magistrates’ and youth courts and on appeals to the Crown Court, which is relevant to the clauses that we are considering in this group.
The changes in the appeal mechanisms from the magistrates’ court to the Crown Court would not, in my submission, reduce the backlog but would undermine faith in our criminal justice system. I say this because in the present system, which works well, a person who is convicted or sentenced in the magistrates’ or youth courts may appeal as of right to the Crown Court. If it is an appeal against conviction, there is a rehearing of the charge before the Crown Court judge and, usually, two lay magistrates. Vexatious appeals are avoided by the fact that if the defendant chooses to spin the wheel on a spurious appeal to the Crown Court then there is a risk that the sentence can be increased. This sensible measure is, oddly, abolished by the measures in the Bill.
At Second Reading, I reminded the House of some vital statistics in relation to this measure. Appeals against conviction represent just 0.4% of the Crown Court case load. The annual total to June 2026 is 2,418 appeals. Of those, 976 were successful, giving an overall success rate of 40%. However, that figure included appeals that were abandoned at court or before the hearing date. It is more relevant to look at the 1,746 contested appeals. As I noted at Second Reading, 56% of those contested appeals were successful. As a number of noble Lords noted at Second Reading, this shows a system that is working well and provides a valuable safeguard against summary justice in the magistrates’ court.
I ask the Committee to consider excising Clause 6 from the Bill. All that clause does is introduce Schedule 2. I also ask for Schedule 2 to be excised from the Bill, by extension. That schedule will remove the automatic right of appeal from the magistrates’ court to the Crown Court and change the mode of appeal from a rehearing on the merits to a review of the safety of the conviction. All the key decisions will be taken by a Crown Court judge alone. The role of the lay justices in the Crown Court will be axed.
That step is regrettable for a number of reasons. It will remove an element of justice for the defendant considering the person who will hear the appeal, in that it will remove the non-lawyer input into the appeal. Furthermore, it will remove the valuable expertise provided by the lay justices to the Crown Court judge when the judge is hearing an appeal on a topic that does not often come before the Crown Court—for example, a conviction on a traffic measure, a trading standards measure or another summary-only matter that is usually heard before the magistrates’ court. All that learning will not be available to the Bench hearing an appeal.
Seven points arise. The first is that the current system is swift and cheap. As I have already highlighted, it is also effective in remedying injustices in the magistrates’ court by appeal to the Crown Court. The system proposed by Schedule 2 is a multiple-stage system. It will require an application for permission to appeal, which we will see in a moment.
Furthermore, the new system will consume more time in the Crown Court, in that Crown Court judges will have to provide time in their diary to consider applications for permission to appeal, more often than not from litigants in person. They will need to discern, from an AI-generated transcript, the reasons why the magistrate came to their conclusions. They will need to determine whether there is a basis on which they should grant permission. If there is not, they need to give reasons for not granting permission. All that appears not to have been built into the whole purpose of the Bill: to cut the backlog in the Crown Court. The question I posed at Second Reading was: will this measure save time? It is clear to me that it will not.
The second point is that the current system is fair and effective. The majority of contested appeals are allowed—a point I have already echoed.
The third point, which was very unsatisfactorily answered by the Minister in his Second Reading response, is that the Law Commission is about to report on this very issue. Since 2022, the Law Commission has been working on a comprehensive review of the criminal appeals system in England and Wales. The Law Commission published its consultation paper in February 2025. The consultation has closed and we await the Law Commission’s final recommendations.
The fourth point is that the Bill’s proposals are directly contrary to the Law Commission’s provisional recommendations. At paragraph 5.86 of the Law Commission’s provisional recommendations it recommended, provisionally, the retention of the current system of automatic rights of appeal. The answer given by the Minister to this is, “Well, we’ve had Lord Leveson’s report since and we prefer Leveson”, if I might noun the noble and learned Lord—if one can noun a verb, or verb a noun. In any event, the short point is that the Government’s answer is, “We don’t want to wait for the Law Commission; we simply want to enact Lord Leveson’s proposals”. That is a mistaken approach. The Law Commission is highly expert and has conducted a detailed analysis of the review of appeals mechanisms. The appropriate thing would be to wait and consider the Law Commission’s conclusions before legislating on what we should do in relation to appeals from the magistrates’ court.