L

Lord Burnett of Maldon (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 16 November 2026

Debate

Courts and Tribunals Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I declare an interest: I remain a member of the supplementary panel of the Supreme Court. It falls to me to introduce the amendment in the name of the noble and learned Lord, Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd, supported by me and by the noble and learned Lords, Lord Phillips of Worth Matravers and Lord Bellamy. In Committee last week, the noble Baroness, Lady Chakrabarti, referred to us as the “exquisite quartet”. I think we have all rather enjoyed that appellation, but I regret to say that only two of us are here this afternoon—the noble and learned Lord, Lord Phillips, and me—so we are reduced to a duet. Were your Lordships in the Wigmore Hall, you would be asking for your money back, but we will do our best. I am afraid that the noble and learned Lord and I also have to be elsewhere from the early evening at something from which it would have been enormously discourteous to have abandoned ship. I hope your Lordships will forgive us for not staying for the rest of Committee today. There are many amendments on which we might have been interested in making one or two observations. We do not support the proposal of the noble Lord, Lord Murray, to remove these provisions from the Bill altogether, but our amendments, starting with Amendment 37, seek to fortify the arrangements that need to be put in place before these new appeal provisions can sensibly be introduced. Amendment 37 seeks to ensure that there is appropriate training in this matter for magistrates, district judges and legal advisers—we regret that we misnamed them as “clerks” in the draft amendment—that there be recording facilities in the magistrates’ court, that there be transcription services for those recording facilities and that, critically, offices be established to assist the judges of the Crown Court in the administration of the hearing of appeals and permission applications. We also suggest that the Lord Chancellor must make a written statement when all those arrangements are in place. Consequent to Amendment 37, we have Amendments 65 and 73, which seek to prevent Sections 1 to 6 coming into force until such a statement is made. We should emphasise that, although we speak of Sections 1 to 6, our real target is to ensure that the courts are ready to operate the new appeal provisions before they come into effect. We also have Amendment 47, which would provide for the right of oral renewal after a refusal on paper of the grant of permission to appeal. This amendment provides for the court to operate in just the same way as the Court of Appeal Criminal Division operates at the moment. Since the new proposals seem entirely to rest upon the process within the Court of Appeal Criminal Division, it is difficult to see why this should not also apply for appeals between the magistrates’ court and the Crown Court. As the noble Lord, Lord Murray, has reminded us, the proposal in the Bill affects only one avenue of appeal from the magistrates’ court—the appeal as of right to the Crown Court. It is right to say that the noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson, recommended that the existing unfettered right of appeal to the Crown Court, which, as has been mentioned, entails a full rehearing, should be replaced with a requirement that the defendant apply for permission to a judge of the Crown Court, and that the grounds of appeal against both conviction and sentence be made the same as those that apply at the moment between the Crown Court and the Court of Appeal. However, the proposal from the noble and learned Lord was developed in the context of his central proposal, which was a Crown Court Bench Division, and not in the context of more serious cases being transferred to the magistrates’ court. We would suggest that is a significant difference. The overall proposed test for granting permission, and then whether an appeal should be granted against either conviction or sentence in the Crown Court, is exactly the same as currently applies in the Court of Appeal Criminal Division.

More from Lord Burnett of Maldon (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.