V

Viscount Hailsham (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 16 November 2026

Debate

Courts and Tribunals Bill

Contribution

My Lords, in this group of amendments the principal question is whether Clause 6 and Schedule 2 should form part of the Bill. My noble friend Lord Murray set out very clearly the provisions that he thinks should be removed—namely those ones. Like him, I am strongly in favour of retaining the unrestricted right of appeal to the Crown Court in respect of convictions and sentences imposed in magistrates’ courts. My noble friend’s arguments, all seven of them, are extremely powerful and I agree with him. I note too that, at Second Reading, his arguments attracted a formidable coalition of support—from my noble friend Lord Howard of Lympne, of course, but also from the Labour Benches. The noble Baronesses, Lady Chakrabarti, Lady Mallalieu and Lady Kennedy of The Shaws, were all supportive of the position adopted by my noble friend, as were the noble Baronesses, Lady Jones of Moulsecoomb and Lady Fox of Buckley. So there is a considerable body of informed opinion. Given the contributions that they have made and doubtless will make today, I will confine myself to noting just two points in support of my noble friend. The first, which he made at Second Reading and today, is that, of the contested appeals, 56% are successful. That surely demonstrates the need for an unrestricted right of appeal. The second point that my noble friend made was that appeals against conviction constitute only 0.4% of the Crown Court’s workload. That demonstrates, if it needed to be demonstrated, that these appeals do not add to the backlog. Against the possibility, even the likelihood, that the Government will seek to ram these proposals through Parliament using their oppressive majority in the House of Commons, this Committee should seek to improve the Bill. In that respect, I do not agree with my noble friend, who shrank from that, and it is in this context that I have tabled my eight amendments that are intended to address that. They fall into two classes, substantive and procedural. I turn first to the substantive. I suggest that the permissive ground should include the interests of justice, so that permission to appeal must be granted if the interests of justice so require. Such a criterion accords with the principles of natural justice, and I am bound to say that I cannot think of any principled objection to that proposition whatever. Such is the effect of Amendments 39, 40, 41 and 42. Then I turn to the procedural points that I have sought to address in my amendments. I suggest that the permissive regime should entitle the defendant to make oral and written representations to the judge. If the former, there would have to be a hearing; such is the effect of Amendments 43, 44 and 45. The Bill, as drafted, provides that a hearing depends on the discretion of the judge. The judge is not obliged to hold a hearing; he can decide on the papers alone. I regard that as very unsatisfactory. The other procedural change that I recommend to this Committee is the subject of Amendment 46. This would provide that all relevant parties have available to them all the appropriate material that they require. This includes a recording of the proceedings in the magistrates’ court and, if appropriate, a transcript of those proceedings. As the noble and learned Lords, Lord Burnett and Lord Thomas, spoke of today and at Second Reading, this raises serious questions of procedure, funding, administration and legal aid. They are very complicated and demanding questions, and these practical issues, leaving aside questions of principle, may of themselves be sufficient to persuade the Committee that we should stick with the unrestricted right of appeal. To summarise my position, I am very much with my noble friend in his substantive arguments; I agree that we should delete Clause 6 and Schedule 2. But, against the possibility that the Government will not agree with this eminently sensible proposal, we need to improve the Bill. It is for that reason that I have taken the liberty of tabling eight amendments with that objective in mind.

More from Viscount Hailsham (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.