B

Baroness Fox of Buckley (Non-Afl)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 16 November 2026

Debate

Courts and Tribunals Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I speak very much as a layperson and may not understand all the nuances and details of how the law works, so forgive me. I support the removal of Clause 6 and Schedule 2 from the Bill, as put forward by the noble Lord, Lord Murray of Blidworth, who explained incredibly well all the details of why it is important. There is a lot at stake in this group of amendments, because of what it potentially represents. The denial of the automatic right to appeal could lead to serious injustices and that is not, I am sure, what the Government intend. I also back Amendments 40, 41 and 42 from the noble Viscount, Lord Hailsham, because, at the very least, it should be made explicit in the Bill that the right to appeal should be granted if the interests of justice require it. I can see no reason why the Government could object to that. How could they say that that was a problem? What is at stake here is the risk of unfair, unjust outcomes in magistrates’ courts if the defendants are unable to exercise their right to appeal. We should have at the forefront of our minds that such decisions could see an individual being locked up and deprived of their liberty for up to two years. I must press the Minister: why is the clause in the Bill? I do not understand it. As we have heard, there is no evidence that defendants’ right to appeal has been exercised frivolously or vexatiously. So, why remove a vital safeguarding right against wrongful summary conviction or excessive sentences imposed by magistrates? On the statistics that the noble Lord, Lord Murray, gave on the overturning of certain numbers of convictions and sentences, I remind the House what that translates into: approximately 1,000 miscarriages of justice were corrected via the appeals route. That is an important gain for the justice system, which we should celebrate and pat ourselves on the back for, not now start denying. At Second Reading, the noble Baroness, Lady Mallalieu, reminded us that the Post Office workers were wrongly convicted in magistrates’ courts. I want to know what would happen to them under the Bill if they lost the right to have a rehearing in a Crown Court. What is even more baffling is that removing the statutory right of appeal will, as we have heard, not fix the Crown Court backlog. Indeed, the campaigning charity Justice has pointed out that the replacement of our effective automatic right to appeal magistrates’ decisions with a multistage permission system is complicated and—this is the key point—highly likely to be inefficient. What work have the Government done on the practicalities here? I am worried that the clause would, for example, make it almost impossible for those who might wish to appeal to be able to negotiate the complexities of legal rules et cetera. That is why I support Amendment 46 from the noble Viscount, Lord Hailsham. Given that many individuals who appear before magistrates are unrepresented, how will they access audio recordings, written transcripts and other relevant information if left to their own devices? How will they come up with sufficiently robust legal arguments, or even apply for appeal? Who will help defendants find lawyers to assist them in preparing grounds for appeal? The bizarre bit of this is that the Government seem to believe, wrongly in my opinion, that juries comprising 12 ordinary people will not be able to cope with complex fraud cases and will want to dispense with jury trials in those instances. Yet the same Government seem happy to abandon an individual layperson seeking to appeal a magistrate’s decision, leaving them to their own devices to draft complicated legal arguments to justify why a sentence or conviction should be further considered. That seems to me to be completely contradictory and, I am afraid, a recipe for injustice. So I hope the Government will look seriously at this issue and drop Clause 6 and Schedule 2. At the very least, I hope they will give some responses to those of us who are concerned about the practical problems that this will achieve and how it is better to enhance justice rather than lead to a lack of justice.

More from Baroness Fox of Buckley (Non-Afl)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.