B

Baroness Fox of Buckley (Non-Afl)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 16 November 2026

Debate

Courts and Tribunals Bill

Contribution

My Lords, Amendment 50 was convincingly and elegantly argued for by the noble Baronesses, Lady Levitt and Lady Brinton, but I want to raise some concerns about it that are slightly different to those raised by the noble Lord, Lord Anderson of Ipswich, although he gave me food for thought. One of the things that concerns me is the idea that juries particularly need direction on myths and stereotypes in trials, particularly for sexual offences. That seems to me to be rather unnecessary, unfair and unevidenced, and potentially undermines juries’ reputations, and is arguably based on some myths and stereotypes of who is on a jury. It is important that we understand that juries have been able to weigh up and assess what happens in the courtroom very well. We have just seen a jury trial—I am referring to the Russell Brand trial—in which the jury negotiated its way through all sorts of legal verbiage and lively exchanges in the courtroom that might be said to have used some of such myths, and yet the jury managed to sift through all of that and came out with nuanced verdicts on a range of charges. Generally, in rape trials, juries are more likely to convict than acquit defendants. This is one reason why so many of us were unhappy that one of the original arguments used to justify the restriction of jury trials was that it was to deliver a swifter and fairer justice system for victims, in particular those affected by violence against women and girls. Some of us just felt uncomfortable that this was hiding behind victims. We heard a slight echo of that earlier, when the noble and learned Baroness, Lady Smith of Cluny, used female victims in particular to justify removing the automatic right to appeal. That always makes me feel rather anxious. I was glad to hear the noble Baroness, Lady Levitt, assure us that this is not an attempt to interfere in juries’ independence, but there is a danger that it could potentially have a chilling effect on barristers defending the accused, and we need to ensure that defendants get a fair trial. It is important that we always remember that the people being defended also have to be heard, and there are lots of myths and stereotypes around that as well. I worry about a potential political football being used and statutory overreach. Amendment 50 seems to mirror the views of the Secretary of State for Justice, Alex Norris, who only today announced that he has written to the Bar’s disciplinary body complaining about lawyers using rape myths, saying that barristers should face disciplinary action, including being barred from practice, if they do not comply. However, evidence needs to be robustly tested in court and that can mean pushing complainants. It can be uncomfortable, but barristers surely must be free to run their cases as they see fit and do their best in defending their clients. The jury must be able to hear all this and draw its own conclusions without interference or overreach from Parliament into the criminal justice system. Ensuring a fair trial is equally important as what can sometimes be over-interference on behalf of women victims, when, in fact, that is a political question rather than a legal one.

More from Baroness Fox of Buckley (Non-Afl)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.