Contribution
My Lords, it has been humbling to listen to a lot of the speeches, and I particularly pay credit to the noble Baroness, Lady Neate, and her vast experience in the field of domestic abuse. In general, I am a great admirer of her work, but I support the removal of Clause 16 from the Bill because it is unnecessary and could have unintended consequences.
There has been a lot of confusion, if not misinformation, about the present status quo. Somehow the legal presumption that the involvement of each parent in the life of a child is good for a child’s welfare has become problematised and even demonised, and, worse than that, associated with abuse, although the current law obviously includes safeguards to restrict the involvement of either parent where it is detrimental or dangerously unsafe.
I was reflecting on the points made by the noble and learned Baroness, Lady Butler-Sloss, about the presumption not being needed. When it was brought in, I thought that, but the problem now is that it is within the law, and I am concerned about what the message will be if it is removed. Indeed, the Government have said that its removal would send a message, because it is implied that the presumption has been the cause of some of the real tragedies that we have seen.
Given that there is gap in what is happening, there is a need for greater accountability for any state failures that might contribute to the awful, tragic deaths of children that we are all so vividly familiar with, and that are at the forefront of our minds, which are so often associated with domestic abuse. It is absolutely appropriate for us to identify any shortcomings in family court practices or those of any other state bodies. I am all for a culture change in the family justice system and for improved risk assessment, and I think the child-focused courts and specialist domestic abuse services proposed in Amendment 53B, in the names of the noble Baronesses, Lady Barran and Lady Neate, should be seriously considered. However, I stress that there is no empirical evidence that a statutory presumption of parental contact is connected in any way to the kind of tragedies that are at the forefront of our minds.
Overturning the law could become a convenient scapegoat, but it would not help any child at all, and it might do some damage. The principle that both parents matter to a child’s welfare is an important principle to hold on to, and to suggest otherwise represents another type of threat to a child and their welfare. That shift could send a divisive message, which might further inflame relations between bitter, separated parents in a way that is converse to the point made by the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, that it could become weaponised and lead to more toxic accusations.
It is always grim when one parent tries to poison a child’s opinion of another parent or a child gets tossed around. One hopes that the courts would see things out, calm things down and act in the best interests of children—and one admires the courts most when they do so—because children want the love of both parents and a relationship with both parents. Sometimes, it can be difficult to juggle all that. More often than not, children love both their parents, even if their parents do not love each other. It is a messy area for the state to have to get involved in.
In the midst of that, I want to counter the derisory, insulting war against what has become known as pro-contact culture. In that sense, I welcome Amendment 53, from the noble Lord, Lord Farmer. Adding a parental relationship test to a welfare checklist for any child seems an elegant idea and a way of countering some of the more negative views of parental contact as problematic. An important part of the amendment is the requirement that judges evidence their reasoning on key decisions. This seems to be lacking in the discussion on this part of the Bill.
Finally, the proposed requirement in Amendment 53A for an independent evaluation of the outcomes of this repeal of the presumption of parental involvement is essential. The measure may lack evidence. I do not want the Government to abolish it and I do not think they have the evidence to abolish it, but, at the very least, the Government should gather evidence on its outcome if they do abolish it. That is why Amendment 53A has my support.