B

Baroness Kitching of Penistone (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 16 November 2026

Debate

Courts and Tribunals Bill

Contribution

My Lords, before I start, I offer my apologies that I was not present for Second Reading on 27 October. I hope that noble Lords will grant me their forgiveness for that, as I was not introduced to this House until 2 November. Iusb have, however, thoroughly brought myself up to date with the debate via Hansard. I speak in support of Clause 16, on the repeal of the presumption of parental involvement. In doing so, I note and give thanks to the honourable Member for Peniston and Stocksbridge, Marie Tidball, for her tenacity and determination in ensuring that this clause is in the Bill. I have a particular reason for wishing to speak on this matter. Clause 16 is Jack and Paul’s law, as we have already heard this evening, which is named for the beautiful sons of Claire Throssell. The boys, aged 12 and nine, were killed in a house fire in Peniston, the town where I live, in 2014. That fire was set, deliberately, by their father, a known domestic abuser, on a court-ordered unsupervised contact visit. I have known Claire for very many years, because everyone in Peniston knows Claire, the tragedy that she has endured, and how the community pulled together to support her. I remember the day that that news broke, and the grief that was and is still felt by the whole town. I have watched Claire campaign bravely and fiercely to fulfil her last promise to her boys that no more children would die at the hands of an abusive parent. She has done incredible work as a survivor ambassador to protect victims and children—I know that many noble Lords are well familiar with her and her work—and she has won awards and accolades for that, including an MBE in 2021. As Claire’s local councillor since 2018, I have offered her my support and my love, but I have been powerless to offer anything further. When I was appointed to this House, I promised her that I would speak in support of Jack and Paul’s law in this Chamber, with a view to completing the excellent work done in the other place on this matter. It really is an honour to do so today. Presumption has no place in keeping children safe. By “presumption”, I refer to the double presumption laid out in the Children Act, as has already been stated by the noble Baroness, Lady Neate, that the involvement of a parent in a child’s life “will further the child’s welfare”, but also that a parent is presumed not to be a risk of harm to the child unless there is evidence to the contrary. It is on that second part of the presumption that I wish to focus. It places an overwhelming burden on victims and survivors of domestic abuse to prove that that risk exists—on survivors such as Claire, who was kept in silence, shame and isolation for 16 years of marriage by a constant barrage of physical, emotional and financial abuse, and on children such as Jack and Paul, who lived in the shadows for their entire lives, witnessing, hearing and experiencing that abuse but unable to speak up for fear of worsening the situation and putting their mother at risk. However, please do not think that this is about one case or a handful of tragic cases. The former Government’s own harm report, published in 2020, attests to the fact that this burden is too great and the threshold of proof is too high. Moreover, UK law has changed and progressed since 2014. The ways in which that has happened have been laid out in detail by the noble Baroness, Lady Neate, so I will not repeat them now. Evidence from the Domestic Abuse Commissioner’s 2025 review of child arrangement cases found that domestic abuse—including coercive and controlling behaviour, witnessing abuse and post-separation abuse—was a factor in 87% of family court case files, and the most likely outcome of all those cases was unsupervised overnight contact with a non-resident parent. Sometimes, that unsupervised contact has devastating consequences. Claire’s experience, sadly, is not unique. We know of 19 more children who have died at the hands of domestic abusers since Jack and Paul were murdered in 2014, making a total of 68 child homicides since Women’s Aid started researching the issue. It was fascinating, earlier in this debate, to hear the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, refer to the 68 children who were murdered by a parent as not benefiting from parental contact. That feels quite the understatement.

More from Baroness Kitching of Penistone (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.