Contribution
My Lords, a week ago I took part in a debate here on the desirability or otherwise of a written constitution. I was put on the speakers’ list to follow a slew of noble and learned Lords whose knowledge, experience and fingertip ability to bring out the right quotation and citation was extraordinary and belittling. This week, I am put on the speakers’ list to follow diplomats, politicians and others who have run the world or been close to people who have run the world. Here I stand now, seeking to make as much sense and legitimacy for my being here as I tried to make last week. The feature in common for both debates is the noble Lord, Lord Anderson of Ipswich. I am now so used to the noble Lord that his presence is comforting; last week, it was less so.
I want to move from macro to micro, and those who know me will not need much help to understand that I wish to speak about a country that is very dear to me, namely Haiti. I lived there for 10 years and did all kinds of things, from microfinance to organising co-operatives, planting trees, literacy and working with Haitian people in the fields and the council chambers, sometimes in the midst of alarmingly hostile situations. I come from that experience and it allows me to declare, as a possible conflict of interest, my co-chairing of the Haiti APPG. I was also ordained as a Methodist minister in Haiti. Our two sons were born there in a local hospital with Haitian medical care, so nobody could ever accuse me of being impartial as I share my remarks with the House today.
Three items concerning Haiti have come to my attention in the few days since I put down my name to speak. First was the news that the United Nations has agreed to extend its remit to maintain a Gang Suppression Force in Haiti for a further six months. Secondly, one of the countries providing troops to that force is Sri Lanka. Some 1,500 of its soldiers have been present in Haiti since June. Thirdly, there was a long article in the Spectator by a man called Bruce Gilley under the headline
“It’s time to colonise Haiti”.
I found it provocative, ill informed and malicious. That is not untypical of the approaches to encapsulate or describe what is happening in Haiti.
Despite the longer time than usual which is now allotted, time limits me to just two of those items. Between 2004 and 2007, at least 134 Sri Lankan peacekeepers sexually exploited and abused Haitian children, boys and girls, some as young as eight, anally and orally. This was revealed by an internal United Nations report; it is excoriating to read. None of these peacekeepers was imprisoned for sexual assault or misconduct or brought to justice. There is no evidence of any credible, transparent or independent vetting process for troops constituting the present deployment from Sri Lanka. The complete absence of such measures is causing great concern to members of the Sri Lanka Campaign with whom I have been in conversation. Yet 1,500 Sri Lankan soldiers are on Haitian soil again. It is doubtful that many lessons have been learned from the previous dreadful experience.
Such happenings seem to be a regular occurrence in Haiti. Let us remind ourselves that the country suffered an enormous earthquake in January 2010. Over a quarter of a million people died—more than twice the total number of people killed in Nagasaki and Hiroshima combined. The world made a show of rallying round and the United Nations strengthened what it called a “stabilisation force” to keep order on the streets, but abusive events seemed to flourish in the chaos of those times. Uruguay was forced to recall five of its peacekeepers from Haiti in 2011 amid allegations that, while wearing their country’s uniform, they were involved in the sexual assault of a local young man. Apart from that recall—even though there is much informal sharing of information that cannot be ascertained—no further investigation was mounted.
In the same year, an internal investigation conducted by Oxfam revealed that some aid workers, including the charity’s Haiti director, used local women. They were shamefully described as “prostitutes” as if they bore some of the blame for what was happening. All they had post-earthquake was their bodies; nothing else could earn them a penny or two. That they took part, therefore, in what were called “orgies” among the development workers under the aegis of Oxfam was a horrid thing. Amid widespread allegations of a cover-up, details of that 2011 event did not become public until 2018.
Peacekeepers from Nepal were accused of being responsible for a cholera outbreak, subsequently proved to the satisfaction of the investigation, which has killed as many as 10,000 in Haiti—a country that had never known cholera before. Compare the blanket of silence that has fallen on this experience with the publicity given to the incidence of Ebola in Sierra Leone at roughly the same time, and in the Democratic Republic of the Congo in more recent times.
Then there is Donald Trump, bless him; I paused for effect there but I did not seem to get it. In the 2024 election he and, please note, his Vice-President alleged that Haitian immigrants were stealing and eating their neighbours’ pets. There were no credible reports, police records or substantiated evidence of pets being stolen, harmed or eaten by Haitian immigrants.
The grotesque Mr Trump repeatedly referred to Haiti as a “shithole” country, an adjective which, if he continues on his present course, might become useful to us all in our attempts to describe his country. He has begun the process of repatriating 300,000 Haitians to the land of their birth, where 10 million are already subjected to poverty of an order almost impossible to understand; it is the poorest country in the Western hemisphere.
I call these observations that I put together for this talk a charge list. The United Kingdom is a permanent member of the United Nations Security Council. The United Nations has signally failed to engage with the needs of Haiti. The hundreds of millions of dollars it has poured into Haiti for various iterations of peacekeeping, stabilisation or gang suppression forces represents a downright waste of money of the first order. Can our representative in New York show an interest in these matters and see how a fraction of what has been lost and wasted there could have done immense good in the country I am referring to? With that, I rest my charge.