Contribution
My Lords, I begin by joining the chorus of thanking the noble Lord, Lord McConnell of Glenscorrodale, for bringing us this debate and introducing it so clearly. It is a great pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord Ahmad, who, as we have just heard, has maintained an acute focus on gender issues in conflict; I echo his comments by saying that I hope we will continue to see this from our current Ministers. I also note that the noble Lord, Lord Ahmad, did a brilliant job in the recent Lord Speaker’s Lecture with Dr Fiona Hill. For those who missed it, it is on YouTube and I can strongly recommend it.
I am going to focus on three issues. The largest and first is atrocity prevention, which is of course absolutely crucial to maintaining and restoring peace. I have raised this issue previously in your Lordships’ House and it is an acutely urgent one. The noble Baroness, Lady Chapman, referred to the first anniversary of the El Fasher massacre this week. I was at the commemoration in your Lordships’ House of that massacre, an indescribably awful event. We heard there from a woman who described herself as a child of El Fasher; she lost 40 people there. Of course, one of the realities of such massacres today is that she was on the phone to one of the people killed at El Fasher—their children were killed as well—just hours before El Fasher fell. If we think about the kind of experience that people are going through, we must not forget that. She made the plea, so often heard and so often not delivered: “Never again”.
There is a great deal of academic work being done on atrocity prevention, which is worth looking at. The answer to the simple question of why leaders choose to engage in mass atrocities is that they do it because the rewards seem greater than the costs. They end mass atrocities either because they have achieved what they saw as their goal or because the balance of risks and costs has changed. That really is where the international community could and should be coming in.
What we have seen, sadly, is that three of the five permanent members of the United Nations Security Council have increasingly been challenging, to varying degrees, the post-war legal order and seeking to weaken the institutions which should be acting to increase the costs of committing atrocities. For the middle powers—Canada, Brazil, Japan and the UK—that means we have an even larger responsibility to act. As the right reverend Prelate set out, we have a huge moral responsibility, but there is also the practical outcome of why it is in our own interests to take action. Atrocity crimes drive human displacement and destabilise entire regions; many would point to the fact that they disrupt markets and demand costly responses. I note that the Institute for Economics & Peace’s Global Peace Index estimates that such violence cost $2.8 trillion in 2025, equivalent to 18.5% of global GDP.
In November last year, I put a Written Question to the then Minister, the noble Baroness, Lady Chapman, about the staffing level of the mass atrocity prevention hub in the FCDO that was created in 2022. As the noble Baroness told me, it had been integrated into the conflict and atrocity prevention department in 2024. I was asking for numbers in that Written Question and did not get them, so these are direct questions to the Minister and I will understand if he needs to write to me. How many people are now working in that conflict and atrocity prevention department? How does that compare with the number of people working in the department 12 months ago and where do the Government expect the staffing in that department to be in 12 months’ time?
I ask that in the context of an important report that came out earlier this month from the Standing Group on Atrocity Crimes, an independent but very respected group which published The Atrocity Crimes Review: a Comprehensive UK Strategy for Atrocity Prediction, Prevention and Response. The review concludes that
“the UK’s approach … remains fragmented and reactive … there is no coherent framework to ensure … early warnings of atrocity crimes”
and there is now a great deal of academic literature and professional understanding of how we can see these crimes approaching. It says that this is not being “translated into timely action” and that there is
“no comprehensive national strategy, no dedicated ministerial lead, and no clearly identified budget”,
as we have seen from the structural changes I just referred to.
The review stresses that it is talking about successive Governments—it is not picking on any Government in particular—and warns that this is directly affecting the UK’s national security and economic interests. It also has impacts on migration pressures, as well as in the overall application and exercise of the international rule of law. Acting before the atrocity happens not only saves enormous human costs; it saves enormous economic costs. The review recommends:
“A dedicated cross-government atrocity prevention strategy”
with clear funding and parliamentary reporting;
“An independent statutory expert body to assess atrocity risks and advise Government and Parliament”;
and a “named ministerial lead” for these issues, with “stronger mechanisms” to get action. My question to the Minister is: will the Government be looking seriously at this review and responding to it?
I come briefly to two further points, which both relate to the UK’s position in the world. If we are to take action, be regarded as a leader and be effective in that action, when we make commitments to the global community, to scientific researchers and citizens, we need to ensure that we can meet them. I note it has recently emerged that HMS “Protector” will not be deploying to the Antarctic for the 2026-27 season, which will leave the UK without an ice patrol vessel in the South Atlantic for the second year in a row. We last had a vessel, which was the HMS “Protector”, in the 2024-25 season.
That vessel could not sail from Teesside to Devonport this month. Reports suggest that it has suffered a catastrophic double engine failure. This vessel was taken on in 2011 as a short-term replacement for HMS “Endurance”, which had been crippled by flooding in 2008. The vessel carries out surveys and inspections under the Antarctic treaty and it supports the British Antarctic Survey, as well as taking on more obvious defence responsibilities. Can the Minister reassure me that, by whatever means necessary, we will be meeting our responsibilities to the Antarctic treaty and supporting the British Antarctic Survey?
I come finally to a very large subject which I can cover only quickly. The noble Lord, Lord Anderson of Ipswich, spoke, absolutely rightly, about how our diplomats and third-sector organisations have a very good international reputation, but we are seeing worldviews shifting as geopolitics shift. I note that the UN adopted a resolution in March 2026 declaring the trafficking of enslaved Africans as the gravest crime against humanity, and of course the Prime Minister of Barbados, Mia Mottley, has launched a new manifesto from Caribbean leaders asserting their moral, ethical and legal case for reparations.
As noted in a 2024 report by the UCL Policy Lab and Hertford College, Oxford, former colonies are making increasingly vocal demands around the need for reparations for colonialism and compensation for the loss and damage arising from historical industrial emissions. I must cross-reference the Rosebank debate we had earlier: that decision will impact on our international standing in the world, as well as all the other impacts.
Other noble Lords have already referred to some very unwise military interventionism and adventurism in which we have engaged with the US in recent decades. Not being Airstrip One is something that we must think about very hard in terms of our international relations and how we will be treated by the rest of the world. The UK needs to be an independent actor, standing up for human rights and the rule of law. If we are not in that position then we will not be as effective as we could and should be.