Contribution
My Lords, I begin with two quick points. First, to share my noble friend Lord Murphy’s point, we came to the fray expecting to hear solid advocacy for a written constitution and had prepared the finest speeches imaginable against such a proposition, whereas it has not turned out that way at all. Secondly, I had not imagined that I would be speaking at this point in the debate, with all those extraordinarily learned people with huge experience of law immediately ahead of me. Your Lordships must therefore regard my remarks as an entreacte, a little bit of entertainment, between now and when the great heavyweights come on again later.
I want to make a point about written constitutions, whether of the kind that is in the head of the noble Lord, Lord Anderson, as he brought the debate before us, or otherwise. I come from a theological angle—I can see your eyes glazing—with a consideration of, for example, the 500 years it took the Christian church, after the death of Christ, to formulate the Nicene Creed. It celebrated its 1,700th anniversary just last year. To get a form of words that satisfied everybody—it was an attempt to bring an experience out of a Semitic world into a Hellenic world—was itself a challenge, but with the Hellenic, there were a variety of ways of speaking Greek in Alexandria, Jerusalem, Ephesus and other places that demanded only the best intellects, put together to take out of all that something that they could all live with. It went on year after year, decade after decade and century after century. In the end, the great force that brought it into being was a contingent of troops from the Pope in Rome, who put a shotgun—or its equivalent in the fifth century—to the heads of all those gathered for the formulation of the creed.
Those were all the elements going into the attempts to make a written constitution which would bind the Roman Empire, or what remained of it, together. There were more people excluded from Christendom by the creed than included. However, let me move on 500 years, because at that particular time, in the 11th century, there was a proposal to add one word in Latin to the Nicene Creed: filioque. That itself proved so divisive with this written constitution that it divided the whole of Christendom between east and west, Orthodox and Latin. Written constitutions are for the birds. I admire the Nicene Creed, its intellectual process that gave us that form of words and satisfied people for a long time, but it is a historic document. I have never used it—I can say that now only because the Bishops are not here—but, for all that, that is my experience of a written constitution.
I am a Methodist minister. Every year, I get a directory telling me about “who’s who” in my church, together with a second volume that is called The Constitutional Practice and Discipline of the Methodist Church—it is fat. It is the accumulation of all the bits and pieces over 250 years that have allowed us to feel this is our constitutional position—it is fixed. In my early years as a minister, when the manses we lived in were furnished, my wife and I had a bed which had one short leg on it. The Constitutional Practice and Discipline of the Methodist Church fitted perfectly under the fourth leg, and we slept happily ever after. The trouble with that document is that when it was taken overseas to Methodist churches in Africa, Asia and all over the world, that constitution became a substitute for the gospel. The people coming to meetings would be armed with it, and they would say, “But on page 230, it says X and you are doing Y”. At the end of the day, written constitutions lend themselves to nitpicking, oppositionists and uselessness.
I have just half a minute left, so I will do my best. I preached a sermon at Gray’s Inn, the Mulligan Sermon, which was all about the judgment of a man called Richard Atkin, who took all those precedents that constitute our common law and made a kind of overarching statement for it. It boiled down, in the end, to a consideration of the Donoghue v Stevenson case—which all learned Lords know about—which, at the end of the day, allowed him to say that a duty of care and doing unto others what you would have them do unto you will undergird all our attempts, legally and constitutionally, to find the right way forward.
So, there you are. Let the lawyers get on with it now; I will be here to listen.