L

Lord Boyd of Duncansby (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 22 October 2026

Debate

Written Constitution

Contribution

My Lords, this is the first substantive contribution I have made to the work of this House since 2012, when I was disqualified from sitting here by virtue of the Constitutional Reform Act—one of a slew of recent judicial constitutional measures that demonstrate the evolving nature of the constitution. Reference has already been made to the work of the devolved Governments and Parliaments. These are important changes that have been made to the constitutional order through the present arrangements. In principle, a written constitution is not necessarily a bad idea. It may have a number of advantages. In practice, however, those who propose such a document rather underestimate the time and energy that would be entailed by such an exercise, to say nothing of the political controversy that would surround it. To take one example, do the nations of the United Kingdom have the power to secede? If so, on what terms and by what means? In my submission, the issue is not whether we should have a written constitution but whether we have and maintain the conventions, norms and shared values that support our democracy. The noble Lord, Lord Murphy, referred to the constitution of the USSR. Article 112 of the 1936 constitution of the Soviet Union states: “Judges are independent and subject only to the law”. If one looked at that and knew nothing about the Soviet Union, one might think that it had an independent judiciary and was committed to the rule of law. Nothing, of course, could be further from the truth. I submit that the conventions, norms and shared values, the respect for those whose opinions differ from ours, and the respect for human rights and human dignity are of more significance than whether we have a written document. If we look across the Atlantic to the United States—a nation whose commitment to a written constitution is, in effect, forged into its very soul—we can see what happens when these values are challenged. There are too many examples, I suggest, that question its commitment, at least under this Administration, to the values I just outlined. The most egregious example was on 6 January 2021, when there was an assault on the Capitol building. The President’s false allegations of voter fraud and the pressure on the Vice-President, effectively, to overturn the result of the general election challenged the norm that, barring any legal challenge, the result of free and fair elections would be accepted and that thereafter there would be a peaceful transition from one Administration to another. Under this President, we have seen the politicisation of federal prosecutions to go after perceived political enemies, the flagrant misuse of presidential powers of pardon, and threats to journalists and the freedom of the media. While federal judges would no doubt bristle at the suggestion that they allow political leanings and considerations to colour their judgments, it is perhaps remarkable that, in order to understand some of the judgments made, it is thought relevant to question who was the President who made the appointment. This gives rise to cynicism and undermines the authority of the courts. In April 2026 just 43% of Americans supported the work of the Supreme Court, down by 11 points from a year before. These are serious matters, but I am not one of those who believes that America is about to slip into a further authoritarian abyss. However, I suggest that what is happening in the United States is both a warning and a wake-up call. In this country, we face challenges which should be now addressed. Respect for the opinions of others has declined. Public discourse in this country has become coarser, more divided and more challenging. The debate over Gaza and Palestine has at times descended into an ugly form of antisemitism. The language used to describe illegal migrants and asylum seekers is often degrading and dehumanising; every human is entitled to be treated with dignity. Threats to the safety and well-being of politicians and public figures have increased. These will only serve to push good people out of public life. Social media, of course, has played its part. We have also seen assaults on the independence of the judiciary, which were referred to by the noble Baroness, Lady Manningham-Buller. These challenges to the unwritten parts of our constitution, particularly the values that bind us together, will, I fear, only increase. I have no great views on whether we should have a written constitution, but I rather suspect that the energy and time that would be involved in that process would be better expressed by addressing these fundamental issues.

More from Lord Boyd of Duncansby (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.