B

Baroness Manningham-Buller (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 22 October 2026

Debate

Written Constitution

Contribution

My Lords, I speak with some hesitancy, given the expertise of many speakers in this debate. I will not talk for long; I want to say just a few things. I always believed that our constitution was flexible and adaptable, and preserved the sovereignty of Parliament. I can remember a conversation with the President of the Supreme Court many years ago about whether we need a written constitution. He said that in 1930, if you looked at constitutions of Europe, you would have said that Germany had the best one. We have seen other examples and other speakers have shown the fallacy of relying on a beautiful constitution. Of course, the events with the Prorogation of Parliament and others worried us; they certainly worried me. I note, in particular, the Daily Mail story on “enemies of the people”. My father filled all the major law roles of the Crown: Solicitor-General, Attorney-General and Lord Chancellor. He always told me that he tried to do those jobs in a quasi-judicial way, not a party-political way. For example, he objected to Suez on the grounds of its illegality. He also told me that he took an oath to defend the judges if they were attacked. That has not recently happened, and the person in the role of Lord Chancellor or the Minister of Justice should defend the judges. We do not have to agree with all the judgments or all their decisions, but if we do not resist any imputation of the independence of the judiciary, we are in real trouble. A recent Attorney-General had a spad; this is completely wrong in my view. I have twice chaired committees to appoint the chair of the Judicial Appointments Commission, which was established by the Constitutional Reform Act 2005. In each case, I came under some pressure from politicians to reach a certain outcome, which the panel resisted. In MI5, which is slightly different, there were occasions under both Labour and Conservative Governments when we were asked why we were not looking at a particular subject, to which the answer was that, constitutionally, the Government can stop MI5 doing anything—they can sack it, abolish it, sack the leader or refuse to authorise anything—but they cannot tell it what to do any more than they can tell the police who to arrest or investigate. In each case, both for the appointment of the chair of the JAC and in my MI5 experience, when this was explained, Ministers backed off and the constitutional niceties were preserved. My feeling is that all noble Lords need to be sure to resist inroads into, in particular, the independence of the judiciary, which I have focused on, and the other aspects of the constitution which we all recognise; they should not necessarily go into a formal document.

More from Baroness Manningham-Buller (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.