B

Baroness Fox of Buckley (Non-Afl)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 3 November 2026

Debate

Prison (Governor’s and Adjudicators’ Punishments) (Amendment) Rules 2026

Contribution

My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Farmer. When we debated the Victims and Courts Bill, I had qualms about the targeted punishment of withdrawing social visits, even from those prisoners despicably refusing to attend sentencing hearings. I do not like the families, even of selfish, cowardly perpetrators, being used as a stick. Then I thought of the families of the victims, shown such contempt by such prisoners, and I swallowed my concerns. But if ever there were an example of why we should beware laws passed here being weighed down by secondary legislation powers, it is the dangerous slippery slope on display here. It shows another type of contempt: contempt for democracy. No one in Parliament agreed to this mission creep that has amended the Prison Rules to allow restrictions on family visits as a general disciplinary punishment. None of us gave permission for that. Why would we, when it shows politicians’ contempt for any of the common-sense advice or on-the-ground expertise of prison officers and criminal justice campaigners about how real discipline works in prisons? One of the most effective restraints on bad behaviour or criminal activity inside, or indeed on release from prison, is the influence of families and loved ones. Does the Minister understand that the way for a prisoner to have any sense of regret or shame for past crimes, or to be inspired to change, is via their mum, their fiancé, their kids? Not letting them down can be a powerful antidote to getting into further trouble. These social visits can lead to encouragement, even to tellings off, and while it cannot conquer all of the toxicity and brutality of prisons, having to face down your mum can do a hell of a lot. Cutting off this pro-social influence is inexplicably foolish, and it is performative toughness. If the Government really want to be tough on the chaos in too many prisons, then do the hard jobs: tackle the thriving drugs industry behind bars; take on the unchecked growth of Islamist gangs; expose how human rights laws are being deployed to limit staff’s ability to exert authority and impose rules. Do not take the soft option of weaponising family visits. If only the Government used their executive powers to tackle cuts in purposeful activity and prison education, to invest in training and support for inexperienced, overworked staff. I have been involved in the prison project Debating Matters Beyond Bars. The most moving moments have been those prisoner debaters beaming at their certificates because they cannot wait to send them home, and the letters from their wives and their kids saying “It helped him see another future: something to be proud of for his family”. Families are the best rehabilitation aid ever; they are cheap, and you dispense with them at your peril.

More from Baroness Fox of Buckley (Non-Afl)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.