B

Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle (GP)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 9 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, we come now to Clause 10 and what will be a discussion of great interest for many people who have an interest in the Bill, but who are not following the fine detail of organisational structures. It is worth starting by noting, particularly as we have a clause stand part notice, what Clause 10 actually does. It appears to say that the Secretary of State may not vary the proportion of health services provided by the public or private sectors, or by different sorts of legal entity, unless the Secretary of State considers it in the interests of the health service. We will hear later about an amendment from the noble Lord, Lord Kamall, and the noble Earl, Lord Howe, which seeks to change that to the interests of patients. My starting point to the Minister is that this clause appears to aim to fix in place the current arrangements, with their mix of public and private. I think that will surprise many people, given that the mix we have now is in many cases essentially a result of accidents and the outcomes of tenders, not of any sort of plan or systematic thinking. It is also, of course, the result of failures. I am thinking here of an example many noble Lords will remember: the rather infamous Hinchingbrooke hospital case. The private company Circle was running that hospital, but it was such a disaster that it simply handed it back to the state. That kind of historical accident reflects what has happened in our mix of private and public services. I also point the Minister to the article in the Lancet from 2024, entitled The Effect of Health-Care Privatisation on the Quality of Care by Goodair and Reeves. It found “that aggregate increases in privatisation frequently” are accompanied by “worse health outcomes for patients” —indeed, all too often, deadly outcomes—so it is curious that the Government seem to be seeking to fix it at what we have now. That is where we are at and where this discussion is starting. I have three amendments in this group. I am moving Amendment 33 and speaking to Amendments 36 and 51. I will go through them in order, but all three address the same fundamental concern: that we have seen this growing role of private companies in the delivery of our NHS. The Green Party and many members of the public see the need to restore public provision as the organising principle of our health service. Taken together, these three amendments seek to establish a presumption—different to the Government’s current position—in favour of public provision, which I argue is based on the evidence we have before us. They would require a proper review of the existing private sector arrangements and set a clear statutory duty on the Secretary of State to ensure that NHS services are publicly provided. The NHS was founded on a radical idea that healthcare should be available to everyone according to need, not to the ability to pay. But successive Governments have apparently been increasingly comfortable with the idea that it makes little difference who provides a service, as long as the patient does not receive a bill. I would argue that it makes a great deal of difference. Amendment 33 seeks to introduce a presumption in favour of public provision. We have seen a growth in private sector involvement in the provision of NHS services. The House of Commons Library reports: “In 2024/25 the NHS in England spent around £20.4 billion on non-NHS providers. This amounted to 10.3% of its resource budget for that year”. Public money is increasingly being used to purchase healthcare from commercial organisations, rather than building and maintaining the NHS’s own capacity to deliver. The result has been a gradual erosion in the distinction between a publicly provided health service and a publicly funded market in healthcare.

More from Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle (GP)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.