Contribution
My Lords, I draw your Lordships’ attention to my register of interests as a landlord, and as a chartered accountant and chartered tax adviser.
My words are aimed at the self-employed but also a little at landlords. There are 4.5 million self-employed people in this country and 2.6 million landlords. Most of them are very small. I do not know how the Labour manifesto pledge of not raising income tax quite squares with this increase of plus 4% for savers and people who receive rents, but I will leave that to them. We heard much in this Budget about breathing space, but I am afraid there is very little breathing space for the self-employed. They are being ground down under the requirements of Making Tax Digital: it has been confirmed that the £50,000 turnover figure for the year we are in is being reduced to £30,000 next year, and to £20,000 the year after.
Why are we making tax digital at all? I have laid 25 Written Questions to this House on this issue, and much that comes back is very poorly drafted and reflects rather badly on the Minister’s predecessor. The tax gap is often quoted. The sad thing is that HMRC is not even prepared to give the software to taxpayers to make the system work. Taxpayers must go out to the market, find their own software and pay the bill. I see this as quite a sinister change in the relationship between the citizen and the state. Those in business are now having to manage their affairs simply to provide data to the state.
I do not much care how people hold their business records. It can be on bits of paper, spreadsheets or fancy apps. What is important is that they report the right amount of profit and the tax they are on. If people think that making tax digital will bear down on the rogue and illegal traders who are rinsing proceeds of crime on nearly every high street, and that they are suddenly going to become angelic tax-compliant angels, they ought to get out a bit more.
Some might say, “Ah, it was the Conservatives who came up with this in 2015”. That is true, but we never implemented it. Perhaps we are looking at the reason why it was never implemented. I spoke to every Chancellor and every FST during my years in the other place, and by consent it was never implemented during our time. We are now seeing what MTD with teeth looks like. The proposal is for in-year payments, maybe monthly, probably more likely quarterly, from tax year 2029-30. In that transition year we will have the old method of tax payments, which is pretty simple. You make a payment during the year, at the end of January, as an on-account payment—that is within the tax year; you make another one in July, three and a half months later, after the end of the tax year, which is the other half; and then you make a balancing payment, which may result in a repayment or a slight extra payment, depending on how things go at the end of January.
We are told that this is somehow being done to normalise tax payments. The words the Chancellor used were
“bringing more of these taxpayers in line with the majority”—
that is an exercise in doublespeak—
“so that they make smaller, more regular payments instead of facing larger bills that are harder to pay”.
The Chancellor is trying to tell us that this is all for our own good because we cannot manage our own tax affairs. This acceleration of tax payments—no increase in tax—comes to £17 billion, which will not be used for investment in that transition year. I can see a collapse in white van purchases, because people will not have the money to buy them. There will be no money for new employment, and some of those having to pay these in-advance payments will have to go to high street lenders, paying a far higher rate than the Government bear on their borrowing. If GBPLC is meant to be “all in this together”, this is a funny way of showing it.
The key point is to contrast this with companies. Companies pay their tax nine months after the year-end, and there are no changes to that. A big company, with a profit of £1.5 million or more, pays quarterly, starting in month 7. A company with supersized profits, with £20 million or more, has proper quarterly payments, in months 3, 6, 9 and 12. The question to the Minister is: why are we treating self-employed people with small profits akin to a supersized company with £20 million or more?