Lord Mackinlay of Richborough (Con)

My Lords, I have only put forward one amendment to this entire Bill, Amendment 70. I spoke at great length in Committee and highlighted then, as I will highlight now, that I am a chartered accountant and chartered tax adviser, and have conducted probate work over many years. Let us just lay out a little the framework of where we got to in the provision of IHT423, because it will not be familiar to everyone in this House, I am sure. The IHT423 arrangement was first rolled out in 2003 and applied only to banks and building societies, or cash-based liquid accounts. It allowed for the breaking of the Catch-22 situation which executors find themselves in when they administer an estate. An estate is often in two parts, one of which is called the free estate, which is your cash and liquid investments. The IHT on that has to be paid six months after the end of the month of death. The other part of the estate is property and often unquoted securities, where there is a non-liquid market; an instalment basis can apply over 10 years. Given that the new rate of IHT interest chargeable on unpaid tax, following Rachel Reeves’s first Budget, is now 4% above base, so currently 7.75%, then no matter whether it is free estate, payable immediately, or part of the estate that can be paid over 10 years, given the 7.75% interest rate, which is truly penal, most executors would like to pay the tax as soon as they possibly can, and certainly by the due date of six months after the date of death. In the old days, the IHT423 procedure, which is a means by which a financial institution can release funds before probate, was working, because very few estates were hit by IHT. But because of fiscal drag—I will admit as much as anybody else that a lot of it occurred over our Government—the levels of free amounts for IHT have remained unchanged since 2009, which has meant that more and more estates are dragged into the IHT pot. So the IHT423 arrangement, of getting funds out of an estate before probate can be obtained—as I say, a Catch-22 of chasing one’s tail of having to pay the tax before probate can be obtained—was widened to any types of investment. That was negotiated by HMRC in 2024, so fairly recently, in recognition of the huge number of estates that now face IHT.