M
Member
Speaking in the House of Lords on 16 November 2026
Debate
Courts and Tribunals BillContribution
It has always been an anomaly that lawyers have been considered disentitled from reminding the jury of the principle of jury equity when addressing them, and that is the anomaly that subsection (1) of the amendment’s proposed new clause would remove. To that extent, I disagree with the noble Lord, Lord Macdonald, in his saying that a jury should not be referred to the principle of jury equity by counsel in their closing speeches. If they were not so entitled, then they would be debarred from reminding the jury of what has long been considered a cardinal principle of English law: jury equity. Moreover, that is a principle of which many jurors will be aware from their own general knowledge and outside reading. They cannot be expected to refrain from informing other jurors about the principle in the jury room. Without counsel on both sides being entitled to address the issue, where do jurors get their guidance? The judge is going to direct on the law, and the jury are going to decide on their conscience. It is simply artificial to suggest that the jury should not be entitled to receive guidance from counsel on that principle. Jurors should not be kept in the dark about a cardinal principle of law.
About Hansard
Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.