L

Lord Faulks (Non-Afl)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 16 November 2026

Debate

Courts and Tribunals Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I declare an interest as a practising barrister—I am sorry I did not do that in the previous group. I am not a criminal lawyer, although in the long-distant past I both prosecuted and defended rape cases. I was also a recorder in the criminal courts and was subjected—although that is not quite the right word—to the excellent training provided by the Judicial Studies Board, subsequently the Judicial College. It was a very high standard of training, very conscientious, and provided by senior judges. There has been criticism of the level of training that has been offered or is offered. The Judicial College provides training to all courts to judges in England and Wales on behalf of the Lady Chief Justice, whose statutory duty under the Constitutional Reform Act is to maintain “appropriate arrangements for the … training and guidance of the judiciary”. Nobody can deal, as a judge, with serious sexual offences unless they have been on appropriate courses from serious and senior judges, and they have to have an update, which is by seminar on a regular basis. Induction and continuation seminars are each two-day, in-person programmes, with lectures by experienced judges and independent experts. They are provided—to summarise this—with a toolkit, which is regularly updated, almost annually and often more frequently, taking into account delegate feedback and broader developments to make sure that they are reflecting up-to-date evidence. It includes understanding common rape myths, which was referred to by the noble Baroness, understanding complainant behaviour, and the risks of myths and stereotypes biasing juries in some way. I have spoken to a few judges about the noble Baroness’s amendment, and although I think most of them would understand what lies behind it, they have not been enthusiastic about it. I know, for example, that the Lady Chief Justice is not enthusiastic about it. Why? It is because she gave a lecture to the Bar Council in public yesterday to say as much. The noble Baroness referred to the training in the Crown Court Compendium—I think she said she was impressed, although the noble Lord, Lord Russell, was rather bored by it. I can understand that; it is quite heavy going, although I am sure he would agree that it is nevertheless very thorough. It says that judges should alert the jury to guard against preconceived assumptions and approach the evidence without prejudice; that directions may be given at the start of the trial rather than only at the end where the judge considers that appropriate; and that the timing is a matter for the judge in the circumstances of the individual case. It further states that guidance may be necessary, for example, if there is a delay in making the complaint, if the complainant’s clothing is said to be revealing, if there has been a prior sexual relationship between the complainant and the defendant, a lack of physical struggle or signs of injury, or apparent lack of distress when giving evidence. The problem about these cases, as I am sure anyone who has been involved in this will agree, is that they all differ on their facts. What is crucial as part of the Crown Court Compendium is this: directions should be “tailored” to the case and must be given in a fair and balanced way and put in the context of the evidence and arguments raised by both prosecution and the defence, and they should be discussed with advocates and generally provided in writing. It seems to me that it is very difficult for a judge to avoid those very clear guidelines when they will have been trained, and very highly trained. The fact that they should be tailoring to the individual case is surely a matter for an experienced judge to take into account. I fear that this ignores that, and I am afraid that I am against it.

More from Lord Faulks (Non-Afl)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.