L

Lord Macdonald of River Glaven (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 16 November 2026

Debate

Courts and Tribunals Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I can be very brief because other members of the Committee have said much of what I was going to say. Like the noble and learned Lord, Lord Goldsmith, I found the speech made by the noble Baroness, Lady Levitt, extremely persuasive, but I did not agree with her, so I depart from the noble and learned Lord in that. My anxiety is about Parliament prescribing directions for judges to give juries, for all the reasons set out by the noble Lord, Lord Anderson. I am particularly concerned, as he was, about this becoming a parliamentary habit under Governments of different hues. That is a serious and substantial concern, and it is one reason why we have not gone down that route, certainly not since the creation of the Judicial Studies Board—now the Judicial College—which puts so much work into training judges, providing continuing training and crafting these directions. The noble Lord, Lord Pannick, has made clear how detailed the compendium is. It is a model document of its type, probably the best in the common law world. The directions it prescribes are model directions, probably the best in the common law world. As has been said, there may be some judges who do not follow these directions. However, in recent days I have spoken about this matter to a number of judges who conduct these sorts of cases, and, to a man and woman, they have all been aghast at the idea that judges with the tickets to conduct such cases, and undergoing this training, might not be giving these directions. I therefore remain somewhat sceptical about that. As the Lady Chief Justice has said, all trials are so different. They all are so dependent on particular context that great nuance is required in the conduct of those trials by the judges to ensure fairness in the proceedings. This is more likely, in my view, to be achieved by judicial directions crafted and delivered by judges. To be clear, with all due respect to her, I strongly disagree with the noble Baroness, Lady Fox, that these directions are not essential—I believe they are. I hope I can assure the noble Lord, Lord Russell of Liverpool, that, as a former prosecutor, I have the strongest sympathy for the victims of sex crime and a pretty clear, I hope, understanding of what a trial can mean for a victim of rape. But I do not think that any of these issues are solved by Parliament taking upon itself a course of action which could go horribly wrong in the wrong hands.

More from Lord Macdonald of River Glaven (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.