Graeme Downie

Graeme Downie

Labour — Dunfermline and Dollar

Speaking in the House of Commons on 17 November 2026

Debate

The Economy: Impact of Hostile State Activity

Contribution

My hon. Friend is absolutely right: prevention is key to this, as well as making sure we have the capacity in our civil resilience to respond to the threats we are facing and making sure, and I will come to this later on, that the public are fully aware of the threats we face and what capabilities we need to respond to them. We estimate that Russia accounts for as much as 80% of all losses from state-sponsored cyber threats—that was one of the other findings from Moody’s report—with ransomware by far the biggest driver. That works out at roughly £100 per taxpayer per attack per year. That is a very conservative number. Moody’s analysis counted only direct costs to business through downtime, recovery, ransoms and legal bills. It left out the hit to British GDP, public services and households, and it did not include physical attacks. It leaves out the criminal gangs operating from Russia that are not directly state-run. These are modelled scenarios, not forecasts, but a one in 10 chance of a £4 billion hit every single year is a risk that no Chancellor would ignore if it were a flood or a pandemic. Now we have two estimates: one from me and one from a private, credible, modelling firm. Neither comes from Government and I think that should trouble us. The official figure for what hostile states cost Britain should come from the Treasury. I took this report and its findings to the Prime Minister and asked him in the House to commit the Government to collecting this information and publishing it regularly, so the public would know what Putin’s aggression is costing them. He said: “I agree with my hon. Friend about the importance of monitoring the data, and I will see what more we can do on that.” —[Official Report, 12 October 2026; Vol. 791, c. 46.] That is a very good answer and I welcome it, and I feel the argument is beginning to be won. Indeed, last night in his speech to The Guildhall, the Prime Minister named Russia’s “campaign of disruption” and the weaponising of energy and supply chains as a key threat faced by the UK. At the UN in September, the Prime Minister said that the Kremlin spends about £1.3 billion a year manipulating information, and he promised a national resilience public awareness campaign—the fourth recommendation of my “Putin Tax Report”. The Government know what Russia spends on attacking us and are preparing to tell the public about the threat; the one thing still missing is what those attacks are actually costing our economy. We measure the cost of floods and fraud, because the response costs money and we need to know whether that response is working. For hostile states, there is no equivalent.

More from Graeme Downie

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.

For Graeme Downie's full parliamentary record including voting history, expenses and all other contributions, see the Graeme Downie report card.