John Cooper

John Cooper

Conservative — Dumfries and Galloway

Speaking in the House of Commons on 17 November 2026

Debate

The Economy: Impact of Hostile State Activity

Contribution

I apologise for my throat, Dr Allin-Khan. I think it might have been hacked by foreign actors. I congratulate the hon. Member for Dunfermline and Dollar (Graeme Downie) on securing a debate on such an important issue. The book “The New Economic Warfare” contains a chapter on economic aggression, which is apposite. Remarkably, it was written in 1941 and appeared in 1942—nothing new under the sun, then. Although the players and methodology might have changed, the perils remain the same. Such was the consternation of the then Business and Trade Committee when it considered British economic security and how to steel ourselves against foreign interference, it recommended nothing less than the creation of a dedicated economic security Minister armed with an overarching economic security Bill. I was a member of that Committee when those recommendations were issued earlier this year, but they have not been accepted by the Government. Given what we have heard today, perhaps the Economic Secretary might give us a clue as to whether the Government might revisit that Select Committee report. After all, the so-called Putin tax is estimated at around £2.5 billion, as we have heard, which is likely an underestimate. It is money we can ill afford. It would be better spent on myriad other areas. This slow drain is designed to weaken us, to bleed us out and sap our resilience. The Jaguar Land Rover hack put a 0.17% dent in GDP, making it the worst such attack so far. Mystery surrounds the people behind such interference; the euphemism is often “foreign state actors”. The Business and Trade Committee accepted evidence that the latest iterations of the hacking threat sees hostile state actors—whoever they may be—form an unholy alliance with highly organised criminal gangs. These shadowy state actors order the cyber-bullets and identify their targets, and the criminals make the bullets and fire them. It is also clear that much public risk is in private hands. Commercial companies are out there in a danger zone. Their so-called threat surface is vast. Is sufficient help being given to them? A recent headline read “GCHQ warns companies after cyber-attack”—“after” being the key word. “After” is the runway behind the aircraft, not in front. It is useless. Firms with tight margins must purchase and update security software and are not even obliged to report to the Government should they fall victim to an attack. Of course, stigma may play a role in firms not wanting to admit a breach, and the Government ought to help ameliorate that. There is also no coherent approach to the response to attacks. Some firms appear to have paid ransoms, while others have held out. An example of the latter seems to have been the Co-op, which hammered down its own systems and returned to pen and paper in a bid to defeat hackers. I liken their approach to a surgeon removing a patient’s diseased limb: painful, maiming, but necessary. Either way, companies must pay up or pay out to their detriment. Military electrical equipment is often hardened against the electromagnetic pulse emitted by a nuclear weapon. That prevents the equipment being fried by the electrical spectrum from such a weapon. We have heard today from many hon. Members about some of the problems we face. The hon. Member for Strangford (Jim Shannon) made the relevant point that a hoax alone is sufficient to cause absolute chaos, and an actual bomb is not needed. The hon. Member for York Outer (Mr Charters) referenced quantum and the rising threat that poses. Meanwhile, the hon. and gallant Member for Birmingham Selly Oak (Al Carns) was concerned that what we are talking about may be lost in translation if we talk to the public. I gently say to him that his Aberdeen lilt is not that difficult to understand, but on a serious point, we need to inform the public about the dangers we face. Does this not indicate that we ought to be hardening our economy against the shock of hostile state activity? What are the Government doing to shield our economy, which is the very lifeblood of Britain? General Sun Tzu advocated “winning without fighting”. Our adversaries know that cyber-attacks offer deniability and the very real chance of victory without firing a shot. The old adage was that no country is more than three missed meals from revolution; now we may be no more than three failed attempts to pay by chip and pin away from surrender. Why send in tanks when our enemies can cripple our ability to buy food or fuel by attacking banking? We know in the information war that shaping attacks are well underway. As the hon. and gallant Member for Birmingham Selly Oak said, when American and Israeli bombs shattered Iranian command and control bunkers, a series of social media activists agitating for Scottish independence fell silent on platforms such as X. These are the so-called sock-puppet accounts for Tehran’s monotheocracy, which seek to weaken Britain by amplifying the separatist narrative and using the nationalist threat to weaken Britain from within. China knows it can outpace and outmuscle us on the economic front. The UK’s weak safeguards against Chinese subsidies for its industries are a risk acknowledged by this Government but—perhaps feeding the Chinese dragon in the hopes it will immolate us last—they do not set out triggers for escalation, defined response options or the consequences that hostile actors should expect. On this, as with so many other areas of hostile activity, we remain reactive, lacking focus on deterrence before interference occurs. Is the way to protect our economy not to resist external interference and draw together this Government’s unsatisfactory, piecemeal defences under that Minister of economic security, allied to an MOD funded and resourced for the modern era? Should we be sharing intelligence with companies on the frontline of this new grey-zone war? Should a cross-Government security Minister not lead on everything from the physical security of our underwater infrastructure, such as data cables, to cyber-threats and economic coercion, such as the dumping of artificially subsidised goods and products, including steel? Only the Conservatives have a fully funded plan to increase spending to 3% of GDP by 2030. All taxes linger and ratchet one way—upwards, ever upwards. This so-called Putin tax will be no different, and we face a Beijing surcharge on top of that. National security must come before social security. A threat to our whole society demands a response from the whole of society. Government must lead. The public are paying up; when will this Government step up?

More from John Cooper

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.

For John Cooper's full parliamentary record including voting history, expenses and all other contributions, see the John Cooper report card.